Irish P4P list

If Rico knew of Dunne he would murder him. He has a Glass Jaw, one of the worst in British boxing.

McCloskey is the real deal. The White Pernell Whitaker :smoke

 

Your GJ ratings, say top 5?

 

gj :?:?:?:?:?

 

glass jaw

 

I'd go with
1.Lee
2.Duddy
3.Mccloskey
4.Dunne
5.Macklin
6.Sutherland (i know he's only had one fight)

 

Id go.....

1-McCloskey
2-Lee
3-Dunne
4-Duddy
5-Macklin
6-Lindsey
7-Magee
8-Sutherland (ya i know)
9-Gomez
10-Coyle/Murray

 

Top 6 are spot on Healy

 

Its hard to judge after the first 5-6 i think...Opinion based really

 

How can you have Duddy that low?? to be honest thats a joke!

 

WHAT!!!

Why would he be ANY higher?

Have you seen him, have you actually seen him fight?

The 3 ahead of him have the all important word in ability, between them have 2 loses and in comparision to Duddy say Andy Lee looks world class..

I like Duddy but the only thing he has going for him at the moment (last 5-6 fights) is A)Chin and heart and B) 0 loses

You cannot rate him ahead of the other 3, what has he achieved?

You can say Lee hasnt done much, but he has skills for sure..

Christ man

 

what about jamie moore? i know he`s english but he`s an irish champ(due to his irish ma) he ko`d macklin in 1 of the best fights av seen +is a very underated & unlucky fighter + is better than most(if not all) other irish fighters! wit dae ye think?

 

ever heard of a guy(all irish champ) called jamie moore?(i know he`s english, but he`s better than that lot):bbb

 

The Moore than fought Macklin and Jones?
He would fit in about 3rd...

 

Duddy isn't that good, simple as that.

 

I know Jamie and saw the Macklin fight as well as a number of other and I am going to see his next fight in Wigan as well.

Yes he fought for an Irish title but he doesnt consider himself Irish unlike Macklin - thats the reason he's not on the list - good fighter though! :good