Rank these ten fighters (1-10) as you believe them to fall all time.

You're a big boxing fan, aren't you? atsch

 

Mc this, Mc that, can't a slightly pissed fight fan make an honest mistake?:tired

 

:good Probably before you were born son

 

Lots of beer and got into a bit of an argument with an ex Welsh guardsman, nothing serious, but fun nevertheless :hat

 

typical kneejerk reaction

wait a month before making your list

 

See above

 

Well said...its the first time that I have seen Moseley anywhere near the top of anyones top ten list :-(

 

:shock::roflatsch

No offense though:good

 

my picks are above

 

That win would tip the balance and move him above Wright and Calzaghe, and on a par with Lopez and Trinidad.

 

Wouldn't you say losing to Junior Jones a little bit before your prime is more damaging than losing to Winky Wright past your prime and above your best weight? Not that I really disagree with your list, most of these fighters are very difficult to seperate from each other, but I think if Trinidad's loss to Wright is to be held against him that Barrera's losses to Jones should be much more damaging.

Also, why Lopez over Calzaghe? Lopez is more impressive to watch, but he is one of the few fighters who has a weaker resume than Calzaghe. They have similar careers, but Calzaghe has the better resume.

I don't have a major problem with these choices, just wondering.

 

did you rank them from 1-10 of 10-1? i really dont understand

 

1. Morales
2. Barrera
3. McCallum
4. Lopez
5. Mosley
6. Trinidad
7. Toney
8. Wright
9. Calzaghe
10. Marquez

Top 3 are easy and the last 3 are easy. The middle four is a bit of a stretch.