Did you all see Ring magazines new P4P rankings

NO "Guru HITMAN". He's 11. :deal

 

That's one mixed up top ten. Apart from that fact that it has eleven people in it.

If you think Cotto lost to Mosley, and he lost to Margarito, how is he still in there? And Calzaghe isn't top five because you don't like him?!

 

Wladimir should be in the top 10. He has been the most dominant force in any given weightclass over the past few years. I don't think Cotto is overrated though.

 

Congratulations on your ability to, erm, read what I wrote.

 

Head to Head matchups don't entirely determine it. Quick example. You have 10 WWs. Due to styles WW "A" can beat WW "B". However WW "B" can beat any other WW other than "A". WW "A" goes 50/50 with the rest of the crop but can beat WW "B" everytime they fight. Is "A" really better then "B"???? Or does he just have the perfect style to beat him? Use your head dude, before you call my list mixed up :yep And **** Calzaghe. Beating a washed up Jones and looking like **** against Hopkins does **** all in getting him on my top 5

 

No no, I just checked the list I posted....he's still 11 :hey

 

What are you talking about? It's nothing to do with A beating B. It's to do with you having Cotto as one of the top ten P4P fighters in the world when, in your estimation, the only fight he has won in the last year and a half was against Alfonso Gomez...

 

I think Cotto is better then Margo and better then any other fighter, who I didn't put above him on my list. Thats what I'm talking about. Are you slow? You're fine with Mosley being on my list, but not Cotto???? What the hell is wrong with you? atsch

 

I just don't like Calzaghe. Get over it.

 

I expect Mosley is being slightly overrated in the wake of a good win, as in the tradition of P4P ratings. I would have him in the ten - fifteen range I suspect, although I would have to think about that.

 

Maybe it has something to do with Manfredo being one of Clalzaghe's top 5 best wins and a corpse of Roy Jones being in there as well.

 

What's your list, if Mosley doesn't make your top 10??? This should be interesting.

 

I think you just disqualified yourself from being taken seriously...

 

JMM and Pac fought twice (I scored a close win each), however, I think Pac is the better all round fighter, JMM just had the style to give him fits. I couldn't imagine JMM doing what Pac did to DLH and the rest of his resume doesn't stack up to Pac's. Plus he lost twice in his prime to Norwood and Chris John who are not p4p level fighters.

As for Calzaghe, not being able to stand him is one thing (he is not always the most endearing guy granted) but that should not get in the way of objective ranking, if indeed it has.