P4P: Which has more Weight to you, Accomplishment or Who would beat Who?

In your personal p4p rankings, which has more weight to you...resume/accomplishment OR your perception of who beats who?

 

Money!

 

You have to balance both...for example... I have Vic Darchinyan rated higher than Nonito Donaire.

Yes, Donaire beat Darchinyan but since their fight Vic has destroyed Donaire's competition.

Since their fight...
Donaire is 2-0 (2ko's) against Maldonaodo, and Mthalane... respectable opposition, but not the top fighters in their division.

Darchinyan is 4-0-1 (3 ko's) with wins against Mijares, Arce, and Kirilov. All which are top 10 fighters, with Mijares regarded a top 10 p4p guy when they fought. The draw against Z Gorres was highly controversial, and he is also rated in the top 10. He's basically cleaned out the 115 pd. division in the span of months.

So even though head to head Donaire is one up Darchinyan, I rate Darchinyan higher based on his current run.

That's just an example of recent accomplishment over head to head.

 

great example :good

another one, it would be silly to rate Margarito above Cotto now simply for the fact Margo beat him

 

If you are a Mayweather fan, I`d say Donaire is UNBEATEN. And he KO`ed Darchinian. Unless that is resolved, I`d rank Donito higher. Donito just had hard luck on challenging elite fighters due to promoter problems, he`s truly an under-rated fighter.

 

So you feel should they fight again, Donaire would kick vics lil arce once again?

 

i always believe that...in the lest 2-3 years, bhop had accomplish more than Jcal. But why is JC ranked higher than Bhop in the p4p rankings?

 

can somebody erase the loss of cotto there...better make it a no contest rather than award the win to somebody that is stained with controversy

 

:?

 

vernon is not even top 40, but when he beats mosley, suddenly he's top 10...

 

Ask the Floyd fanboys, Who's a more impressive win: beating baldomir or beating Paul Williams.

 

Yes, just because he was unknown, he can still be a top 10 fighter. And he proved his first win wasn't a fluke, ala Quintana, he defeated Mosley twice.

 

Typical... atsch

 

Of course.

 

Figures a floyd ****** like you would equate money made as being the biggest accomplishment.