Who is higher all time p4p, trinidad or calzage?

Who do you rate higher Trinidad or Calzaghe?:think

 

Trinidad for me, yes Joe never lost, but Felix accomplished more....Much better resume IMO.

 

Vote assholes

 

if p4p in terms of accomplishment and historical significance...hmmm,i say trinidad...but we have to see the timeliness element in calzaghe..that timeliness as the best 168 fighter may be enough for calzaghe to surpass trinidad 30 years from mow

 

ill be the first

 

Disagree, soley for the fact that Tito's best wins are WAY better than Joe's IMO.

 

i think trinidad much bigger names and tougher fighters is his resume. plus almost all the fighters trinidad beat were all undefeated or in their prime. trinidad no question what so ever.

 

Agree 100% bro.:good

 

I will keep this short.

The only way to truely measure a fighter's greatness is to see how he did against other great fighters.

On that basis, Tito Trinidad.

 

how can calzaghe be leading the pole. lol.

 

papi

 

Very well said.:good

 

This content is protected

 

You are correct as usual...except Tito>Toney:yep

 

More world titles, more world titles in different weight divisions, better resume. Three critical factors, resume being the most important factor there is and I give Tito a slight but definite edge there. Close but clear for the brilliant Puerto Rican.