My Personal Pound for Pound Top 30...

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Israel Vazquez
5. Shane Mosley
6. Miguel Cotto
7. Paul Williams
8. Ivan Calderon
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Ricky Hatton
11. Vic Darchinyan
12. Chad Dawson
13. Juan Manuel Lopez
14. Kelly Pavlik
15. Nonito Donaire
16. Celestino Caballero
17. Vitalai Klitschko
18. Wladimir Klitschko
19. Jermain Taylor
20. Mikkel Kessler
21. David Haye
22.Tomasz Adamek
23. Arthur Abraham
24. Fernando Montiel
25. Joan Guzman
26. Humberto Soto
27. Chris John
28. Andre Berto
29. Jorge Linares
30. Ulises Solis
31. Joshua Clottey
32. Roman Gonzales
33. Tim Bradley
34. Nate Campbell
35. Edgar Sosa



i strive to make a p4p list so the higher ranked fighter would beat the lower ranked. this is based on perception of which fighters can the p4p fighters beat. accomplishment and resume are a big factor in my personal perception

i put lopez slightly lower than izzy and rafa bec i feel that if lopez fight either those 2, the fight would be too close to call. lopez would easily beat caballero

i put mosley ahead of cotto, for i believe mosley would beat any fighter at 147 except pac if he moves up..ssm-cotto would be a close fight though.

i put darchinyan over donaire because i feel that darchinyan would only lose to donaire and a 50-50 chance against montiel..Donaire on the other hand would have a harder time dealing with mijares and montiel compared to darchinyan. lastly, i think montiel is a close fight for any elite fighter 118 below

i favor taylor to beat kessler in another close match. also, guerrero over linares and soto.

im unsure how good guzman and campbell would be in their new division

 

it's p4p..he is giving more than 12-15 pounds to cazares

 

well yes, but can you just imagine if cazares is not that big, calderon would have no sweat beating him..

 

^^^i just beat my p4p not purely on accomplishment. vasquez and marquez can not KO this guy.. but donaire would KO VD, bhop KO'd pav, and dawson can not dispatch johnson with ease...common, juanma deserve his spot...we all know he is at par with izzy and rafa

 

he would not rule the division if he had the same size as his opponents..p4p rankings is biased against HWs...notice how lennox lewis is only in the 10th place for less than 6 months..that is after he beats tyson

 

it is like a round robin..hypothetical match up p4p... i say, pacquiao would not lose to anybody..the #1 is the guy with lowest number of losses.

i feel that darchinyan with be more dominant to other fighters compared to donaire but if they fight again donaire would beat VD again...

taylor may have beaten bhop. but p4p he would lose to many other guys. marquez is a different fighter now compared to his fight with john

i put cotto below mosley because at this stage nobody can beat mosley at 147 except pac..

 

juanma is at par with izzy and rafa..if he fights them today, the odds would be close..khan has never been in the same league as campbell, diaz or casamayor. if khan fight diaz, he would be a 3-1 underdog