Where Do You Rank Adamek in your Personal P4p List?

Top 15 or so.

 

Tszyu was 36 and considered by consensus in the top three P4P at the time.

Now, you have a 35 year old and a 43 year old in your top four P4P.

So, you would have to agree that how old you are is completely irrelevant for the purposes of these discussions all that matters is how good you are.

 

:good

 

Asero you have the worst P4P lists ever. It is completely illogical. P4P lists are based on recent achievement, you don't seem to even count this.

 

Where's your list?

 

"all that matters is how good you are" - exactly

and basing on the performance in a Hatton fight, did you considered Tszyu a #3 fighter in the world? Or did Castillo looked like top 10 p4p fighter?
Besides, that was Tszyu's last fight, and Castillo's later lost to Lujan.

 

Tszyu was considered top three P4P after demolishing Mitchell, then fought Hatton 8 months later. You can't discount the loss just because he lost. Hatton beat Tszyu because he put in the performance of his life and beat Tszyu in the way that Tszyu had been beaten before.

 

That is true, but you can't say that Kostya was at a top of his game

 

I wouldn't say that. What he was and proven to be was one of the best in the world at any weight at that time, and Hatton beat him into submission.

 

atschatschatsch

Shane's last two fights he beat Mayorga(still good & dangerous) and AM(former overrated best WW in the world)

Cotto's last 3 fights he beat Gomez(keep busy fight), lost to AM(got crushed and quit) & he beat Jennings(part time boxer/drummer, 42nd best WW)

You do the math.

 

Top 10~20.

 

Why did you reminded last three Cotto fights and only two Mosley's? Oh yes, cuz Mosley was beaten by Cotto three fights ago.

 

I went back 3 fights to give Cotto an edge, but it still wasn't enough. If you compare their last 3 fights, you'll have them neck to neck. But p4p is what you've done lately, not in 07

 

I don't do P4P but he is pretty high 1-20ish.