A running count of robberies in 09! add the Juarez draw to the list.

Seems like 09 is the year of the atrocious decision

boxing judges must be on the take they simply cant get it right!
add Chris John to the list of guys robbed so far in 09

Collazo vs Berto Robbery Collazo won
Cintron vs Martinez Robbery Martinez won
Campbell vs Funeka robbery cleary a draw
John vs Juarez John won

 

I don't think campbell/funeka was a robbery. It was close fight and I had Nate winning.

 

Are you stupid?

How was Collazo-Berto a robbery?

It was 7-5 either way or a draw.

How can a fight 'clearly be a draw'? It wasn't a robbery at all. It was a close fight, I wouldn't argue if somebody fought Campbell won by a round or 2, or Funeka by a round or two, you can't say it's a robbery.

Jesus ****ing Christ.

 

atsch I dont think those are robberies...Those were close fights that could have went either way.

 

'clearly a draw' :think:?

 

atsch
None of these fight were robberies they were all close fights that could have gone either way. The problem with ESB is that most people here don't the difference between a really close fight and a robbery. A robbery is Pea-Chavez or Roy Jones against That Korean guy in the olympics:deal

 

It's true. The judges have been horrible this year but to be fair everyone knew that Chris John was not going to get a decision in Houston. I had Chris John winning 116-112 but I knew the judges were going to screw him but I'm just happy they didn't really screw him and give him a loss. I see why International fighters are hesitant to leave their home countries and fight somewhere else.

 

'clearly a draw'-i dont think it was clearly a draw.....it could have gone either way

 

A close fight is not a robbery.atsch

 

I agree apart from Martinez-Cintron. Sergio knocked that ****er out and then decisioned him like 117-111 and still only got a draw. **** Kermit. What ****** name.

I also think John won, but it wasn't a 'robbery'. Like you say, the word is used far to often. It was close but relatively easy to score, and therefore I think you have to give it to John 8-4 or 7-5.

 

The Berto and Campbell fights were close fights but the Martinez and Chris John fights I believe were robberies because I believe that most people saw a clear winner in both fights and when people watch the fights again it will be hard to score the fights and give Cintron or Juarez 6 rounds in their respective fights.

 

Collazi vs Berto & Campbell vs Funeka - Could of gone either way
John vs Juarez - Bad decision
Cintron vs Martinez - Clear robbery x2

'Robbery' is perhaps the most over-used word on this board.

 

Cambell -Funika could go both way or a draw!

the one whos been rob this year so far its Martinez he win 2 times to finish with a draw!

 

shot and overhype are in top5 of the most utulise word in here!

 

Berto won 7-5= NO robbery
Campbell won 6rds +the KDs = Campbell win, again NO robbery
Jaurez vs John was close I thought John won BUT it was CLOSE once again NO robbery

Cintron vs Martinez was the ONLY robbery you mentioned.