Is beating Juan Diaz reason enough for a boxer to be crowned P4P #1?

nope, can't say it is

 

yup and suckballs.

 

We are talking about p4p here okay, It is not something you earn, it is something you just are, or not. A judges scorecard has zero relevance to who you believe is p4p number one. It's how you judge a fighter and how you envision him doing against every other boxer in the sport if everyone was the same size. Why do the majority of people seem to have no idea what pound for pound actually means?

 

If pac retires after his fight with hatton (WIN OR LOSE) and
The RING MAGAZINE puts JMM as #1

OH my GOSH! HAIL!HAIL! :happynew #1 .The Ring MAGAZINE suddently becomes LEGIT and not dicatated by politacal and biased agenda's!!!



















IT BECOMES fukin' LEGIT coz you like it what's written. The dream of JMM being #1 is now a reality coz RING MAGAZINE says what exactly what you wanted to hear. JMM is #1! hi:

















Music to your ears Divac?!:hat

 

Hahahah A dream come true if Pac retires!!!! You only have to wait a year from now.

 

:good

I'm just teasing the #1 fan of JMM!

Yes! If JMM becomes #1 it will be suddenly legit and not dictated by POLITICAL and BIASED agenda's coz he will like what he hears. :rofl

 

Keep thinkin that ****..u MIGHT WANNA CHECK THE LB4LB RANKINGS CUZ PAC IS #1..

WHAT UR SAYING IS THAT TOM MILLER OR DUANE FORD (THE 2 JUDGES THAT SCORED IT FOR PAC VERY CLOSE THAT NIGHT) ARE CORRUPT JUDGES RIGHT??? SO I GUESS THOSE 2 JUDGES SHOULDN'T JUDGE NE MORE CUZ 1 HAD IT 115-112 AND THE OTHER 114-113 FOR PAC....BOTH VERY GOOD SCORES FOR THAT FIGHT...QUIT PUTTIN WORDS INTO MY MOUTH TOO MUH FU34A...PAC IS #1 CUZ HE HASN'T LOST SINCE 2005 AND HE'S PUT ON GOOD PERFORMANCES IN ALL OF HIS VICTORIES..HE IS FIGHTING THE TOP OPPONENTS OUT THERE AND BEATING THEM...HE IS MOVING UP IN MULTIPLE WEIGHT CLASSES! WHEN FLOYD RETIRED HE WENT FROM 2 TO 1 FOR A REASON...JMM WAS A TOUGH OPPONENT AND THE FIGHT COULDA BEEN SCORED EITHER WAY BUT PAC GOT IT...AND QUIT SAYIN I LIKE PAC CUZ IM NOT A BIG FAN OF HIS AT ALL..U PROLLY HAVE NEVER EVEN STEPPED FOOT INTO A RING..I TRAIN DAILY SO GET OFF THIS MUH FU34A AND QUIT POSTING A DAY LATER...GOIN TO SLEEP WONDERING IF IVE POSTED SOMETHIN N $HIT MUH FU34A......

U STILL HAVEN'T ANSWERED MY QUESTION TO...UR MY NEW BIT34 ON HERE AS I KEEP OWNING U WITH THIS THREADrofl:hi::deal

 

I CAN AGREE WITH THIS POST UR RIGHT..ITS NOT ABOUT ANY SCORECARD..

WOULD PAC DESERVE TO BE THE #1 LB 4 LB FIGHTER IN THE WORLD IF HE HAD LOST TO JMM THAT NIGHT?? OFFICALLY OF COURSE:think

 

1ST think this guy Divac gonna do is check my posts..IM ALREADY DONE CUZ U HAVE BEEN OWNED BOI!

PEACE OUT!!!

 

I thought JMM beat Pac by close decision in their second fight and since then JMM has beaten the better comp, as oppsed to Pac who beat the weakest champion at 135 and then a win over a semi retired DLH.

If Pac beats Hatton then i think he should be numero uno.

 

KCD,

You must have overlooked. JMM fought casa on his twilight of his career! CASA hardly proved he was better than sta. cruz. See the fight yourself and get back to me if you really believe casa is better than sta. cruz..

Juan Diaz, was already exposed by good ol' Papa Nate. JMM just confirmed that Juan is nothing but a a product of Hype! :hey


cheers!

 

If it was the exact same fight but the decision went the other way then what does that have to do with pound for pound? They both fought the exact same fight so you'd predict exactly the same results if they went to other weight divisions.... What don't you understand?

 

Beating chubby bull does prove young guns are a disgrace. old bucks beat ya'll up, Amir Khant beat Barrera, Kantsidis Casa. Pav V BHOP. Mosley V MArgcheato. Quality of the youngsters are B class. Props to the senior citizens.

 

Yes.
And it was the way he beat him.
He was under alot of fire the whole dam fight, got his timing together, and beat him pretty dam good.

 

Hell yeah !!

Diaz only had one loss on his resume and before then he had 3 of 4 major belts out of the lightweight division and was the #1 rated lightweight in the world.

That puts Diaz leagues above David Diaz, who was just the sacraficial lamb for Pacquiao ... and who hadn't beat any elite lightweight fighter despite being a champion.

I'm not saying that Marquez should be number #1 but the fact that he knocked out 2 lightweight champions and has accomplished more at lightweight than Pacquiao has - makes for a good argument.