1. Juan Manuel Marquez 2. Manny Pacquiao 3. Bernard Hopkins 4. Israel Vasquez 5. Ivan Calderon 6. Shane Mosley 7. Paul Williams 8. Vic Darchinyan 9. Miguel Cotto 0. Juan Manuel Lopez
Williams and Mosely should be rated above Calderon , IMO at least... which after all, all these p4p lists are
Calderon is the most consistent fighter on the list, and has a good claim to be the most technically gifted as well. Undefeated. His position is warranted.
You're right , he is a great figher, I just don't see him as much of a P4P fighter as Mosely and P.Williams ... on top of that I don't really like Calderon's resume.. L.FW is not much of a division , or at least the people he has beat at L.FW
The guy is doing the only thing he can do with a wak resume, moving up and taking on bigger and stronger fighters. Ricardo Lopez gets enough credit for dominating a weak division, so the same should be accounted for Calderon. For somebody who has never tasted defeat like him, and has showed exceptional skills in the process, P4P 5 is about right as far as I'm concerned. We shouldn't give other guys preference just for being bigger.
:adminMarquez at 10? He should be no lower than 2. Good list Selfkill but I think it's a bit early to have JuanMa in the top 10. Someone like Wlad or Hatton is more worthy IMO.
Sounds about right....however, after Lopez and Vasquez go at it...Vasquez will drop in rankings for sure. P.S. Why isn't Margie in the top ten? Just kidding.
