Who's More "DONE" Ricky Hatton Or Jermain Taylor

He was the man at jnr welter for 4 years? Jermain has shown he belongs in there with the best and could do better in the future, he has always given a fight. Hatton fluffed it against Mayweather and Pacquiao "the heart rules the head" and he charges in like an idiot with no defence plus his punch resistance has gone to that of a wet newspaper. I can't see Hatton being motivated to train hard to pull it off on the big scene again seeing as he knows what is likely to happen so whats the point. I think he will though for the money. There's still Khan, Oscar, Witter and more.

 

Hatton never was something, Taylor was (and still is to a certain extent).

 

Hatton .. taylor can still fight and is younger.

 

Both of them can't box worth a ****, but at least Taylor has a jab...

Too bad he don't use it to set **** up...

 

Bull**** right there....

 

Than you explain to me what he was..:yep

Let me give you the first two letters: W R . . . . . .

 

Hatton was never nothing. Ok can u explain why 25000 people flew over to vegas. Can any other fighter bring that following across.

 

Hattons to Pac was the worst as he was barely competitive and made the same mistakes he did against Mayweather but sooner so I think that is more damaging to his confidence. Jermain can take big positives from the way he started against Pavlik in the first bout and Froch, even his whole performance against Pavlik in their second was nothing to be ashamed of.
How can Hatton go through training camp again working on his head movement and defences when he throws them out the window on the biggest scene? The pressure would be huge to come back from this last blow out and it would have to be a complete miss-match or Hatton gets taken out again.

 

Jermain let both those fights get away from him where Ricky didn't challenge either of them really.

Taylor doesn't seem to have a warrriors heart but with plenty of skill.

Hatton is vice-a-versa

 

What the **** is happening to this sport. Everyone is one ****ing loss away from being done!

Remember when Mosley was done a few years back, he ****ing knocked out Margo and Margos done. This is crazy folks!

 

I think level of competition says a lot here - Hatton destroyed by the 2 best fighters, Taylor destroyed by Froch (who sucks)

but, the manner of Hatton's recent destruction makes me think he will retire.

 

Its true that Hatton's losses were only to the very best, but I think he's been carefully managed throughout his career and could've fought more worthy opponents. I don't think that only Pacquiao and Mayweather would beat him - fighters like Witter, Khan, Cotto, Margarito, Mosley, de la Hoya and Judah would probably have beaten him or given him serious trouble as well as few lightweights that could've come up. Taylor went for Hopkins before he was fully developed and looked to take on all comers.