Floyds Last 3 Vs Mannys Last 3 And Some Strange Contradictions.....

NO OTHER FIGHTER!?!?!

berto-pw-cotto-shane could have EASILY killed oscar in a similar if not worse matter

so this forum should be used as a barometer for meaningful & unmeaningful victories ... as many idiots as there are on this forum...

anyone who said pac would win pointed out

- oscar getting hit against forbes
- and the weight thing

very few people took teh time to analyze this... roach knew all along

 

so you think a prime manny would beat oscar?

i never said i didnt like manny... all im saying is if your going to call floyd a cherry picker you should call manny one as well

if you call manny a great multi division champ.. you should call floyd one as well... im just saying keep it consistent

 

hatton=odlh = quality wins for belts from guys in the correct division
diaz=baldo = bums that had belts
odlh=hatton = guys in the wrong class

is that better

 

yeah but it wasn't a thought....everything roach said came to fruition so it was actually true

oscar LOST HIS SNAP... aka washedup.... i dont know why its not like im trying to take away from manny's achievement.... im not .. oscar was just really washedup

and to be fair....

manny was in the wrong weight class when he fought floyd....

at the end of the day both of these fights null each other out

so **** berto then... margarito would have put oscar out in like 4 rounds. plus he would have had concrete gloves so maybe even faster

im not taking away from teh fact that pac went in the ring and did what he was supposed to..... its not manny's fault that oscar was a washed up - weight drained piece of **** when he walked into the ring.. manny did what he was supposed to.... and manny can blame oscar for being weight drained and dumming down his victory

 

margarito would have killed oscar
as would cotto

 

fair enough...if thats the case.... it hurts mayweather & pac which further supports my points that you have to address them in the same regard

either they are both great multi divisional champs
or they are both in their last 3 fights have picked bums

yeah but @ 154 cotto vs oscar would be a different story.. actually cotto would probably still win but who knows...

shane also knocked margarito the **** out and margarito knocked cotto the **** out... so that is a bad point

 

im making my judgement off styles..

margarito would have bludgeoned oscar to death... oscar really doesnt have defense like that as of his last fight & there is no way he would have won a fire fight with margarito

forget cotto at this point... i personally think cotto would have tko'd oscar except the ref would have stopped it but thats just my opinion

 

i agree.... i wanted to use that point earlier... but it has been a long time since bhop has been at middle... i wnated to use winky @ welter as well but it has been a long time also