I haven't, re-read my post:good That was a couple of years ago, he has done little since IMO. However, with a win over, say, Montiel, I would put him top ten. It would justify his brilliant all-round skills. Hope this makes sense
Like most people, I didn't see a good enough reason to seperate Juan Manuel Marquez and Manny Pacquiao in terms of P4P. I actually had Marquez at number 1 after his win over Juan Diaz, but obviously May 2nd brought on alsorts of changes in the list. Hatton leaving, and with Manny once against establishing himself as the most dominant champion in Boxing today.
anyway heres mine 1.Pacman 2.JMM 3.Bhop 4.Dawson 5.Darchinyan 6.Paul Williams 7.Mosley 8.Haye 9.Calderon 10.Donaire
I think Dawson is too high. Just because Floyd said "Dawson is the best fighter in the world" doesn't mean you have to take his word for gospel. David Haye has no business in a top 10 P4P list.
Unified CW champ? If he beat Wlad would you put him in (two-weight World champ with win over a dominant 'champ')????
50% recent accompishment, 50% overall ability 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Juan Manuel Marquez 3. Bernard Hopkins 4. Shane Mosley 5. Paul Williams 6. Miguel Cotto 7. Juan Manuel Lopez 8. Nonito Donaire 9. Ivan Calderon 10. Vic Darchinyan
Since Vic was beaten by Donaire he has moved up a weightclass and beaten Kirilov (IBF) Mijares (top ten P4P) and Arce (past prime, but challenging) Donaire has done none of this, and when he beat Vic neither were anywhere near the P4P list. Vic has improved. Donaire is as good as he has ever been (fantastic and well-rounded) but doesn't have half the resume Vic has. Although he can surpass him now his promotional disputes are sorted.
In the event David Haye beats Wladimir Klitschko, he would have a very good case for being a P4P top 10 entrant. Not a moment before, however.
yes but the las t time i see Donaire he looked slugish as hell against and african i don't remeber his name, because the figt was very boring.