Which of these is more dangerous? All fans of Pac, JMM, SSM and PBF please discuss.

Mosley can weigh in at 140.. thats not the key, they main thing is rehydrating properly which oscar didnt do. Weighting in at 144 and 147 is basically the same, thats ****in 3 pounds. If he weighs over 155 fight night hes fine.

So Id say the toughest is JMM moving up two divs to fight Floyd

 

Weighing in at 144 and 147 is not the same.

 

No, you are not thinking clearly here, oscar yes was fighting at 154 but it wasnt tough for him to make 154 ( he might could cut 2 or 3 pounds as you saw in the fmj fight, he weighted in at 150 and he was still competitive because HE DID COULD CUT those 3 or 4 pounds but after those pounds he clearly couldnt cut well to make 147 against pacman), fight night he was actually about the same as mosley comes fight night, he was coming in at around 160 same as mosley, the difference here is that mosley is having trouble to make 147 while oscar wasnt at 154 so you are saying "just 3 pounds" but those 3 pounds means a lot for a 37 years old fighter who is struggling to make 147, he is already cutting to much at 147, you can see at how much he weights at fight night(around 160) so those 3 pounds MEANS a lot... so basically what 147 are for mosley is what 150 were for odh against fmj, it was the lowest he could weight while still being competitive, is the same case with mosley but mosley is already cutting those 3 or 4 pounds to make 147, thats why he is struggling to make that weight...

 

a 40 year old killing himself to make weight is the worst.

 

The Pac - Mosley option, definitely. Then the JMM option.

Floyd can more than hold his own against strong welters.

 

luckily for JMM, he is allowed to come in below the limit, he won't have to stuff himself to death before the weigh-in

 

They are lbs apart anyway.

Shane killing himself to make weight is worst specially at his age.

 

What? I lost you

Ok I'll put it simply. I didnt hear a peep in this forum about Oscar weighing at 147 for Pac. As a matter of fact it was the contrary, Oscar made 147 really well and he would retain his speed.

After the massacre, there were about a thousand post stating that Oscar although making the weight (147) didnt gain any weight back come fight night. Im pretty sure that was the problem, not making weight

 

Marquez moving two weight divisions @ 35

 

Marquez jumping two weight division at his age. Void knows this.

 

Mosley is a beast at welter . . . if you people forgot how Molsely dealt with Margarito in his last fight you should watch it again.

That's not only dangerous for Pac . . . that's suicide.