Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

I'm going to get together a number of fights on YouTube that are deemed controversial.

Whenever any of you have the time to sit down and watch the full fight, please do so. I'm not expecting masses of scorecards to come in, just now and again if you have time to pop in and fancy scoring a fight it would be appreciated.

Preferably post your Round by Round scores so we know you've actually watched it again carefully and so there are discussion points.

Next is a brawl between fan favorite Brit Michael Brodie and the teak tough Korean warrior In-Jin Chi for the WBC featherweight title.
​

[yt]bLfylQI2-nw[/yt]

[yt]ILGWX8fLJW0[/yt]

[yt]JUstL2HPnXU[/yt]

[yt]UfB4j6-6MYU[/yt]

[yt]fXMlHFuoujA[/yt]

This content is protected

This content is protected

For

This content is protected

:
GazOC (115-114)
Brick-Top (114-113)
safc1990 (114-113)
bruno's chin (114-113)
achillesthegreat (114-113)
trotter (115-112)
onorway (114-112)
mike464 (114-113)
Guy (116-112)
Benjiabc (115-114)
catasyou (115-112)
icemax (114-113)
Beeston Brawler (114-112)
bringitondown (115-112)
ishy (114-113)

For

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

faisal (115-114)
Betty Swollocks (115-112)
HOYA-UK (114-113)

This content is protected

This content is protected

For

This content is protected

:
draw99 (116-114)
trotter (115-113)
Grievesy (115-113)
GPater11093 (115-113)
Mandanda (116-113)

This content is protected

TFFP (116-112)
Guy (115-113)
GazOC (115-113)
ishy (115-114)
safc1990 (115-113)
bored (115-113)
DirtMcGirt (115-113)
Lee Mc (116-112)
BURNLEYBLUE (116-112)
eborted_l (115-114)
LHL (115-113)
shamrock92 (115-114)
Bill Butcher (115-113)
eborted_l (115-114)
RedDragonBoxing (116-114)
achillesthegreat (115-113)
Boro chris (115-113)

This content is protected

This content is protected

For

This content is protected

:
TFFP (115-112)
safc1990 (114-113)
LHL (115-113)
djoc175 (115-112)
fenian 67 (115-112)
fleaman (115-112)
BURNLEYBLUE (115-113)
HOYA-UK (116-115)
Jeff Young (115-113)
onourway (115-113)
GazOC (114-113)
GPater11093 (114-113)
selfkill (114-113)
Grievesey (115-112)
Guy (116-111)
antcull (115-113)
ishy (115-112)
trotter (114-113)

This content is protected

Bill Butcher (115-113)
Betty Swollocks (115-112)

This content is protected

This content is protected

For

This content is protected

:
TFFP (116-112)
fenian 67 (115-114)
BURNLEYBLUE (117-113)
Beeston Brawler (116-112)
Brick-Top (114-113)
onourway (117-111)
safc1990 (117-112)
Grievesey (115-113)
GPater11093 (118-110)
Boro chris (116-112)
zulander (115-113)
antcull (115-114)
trotter (117-111)
thesham01 (116-112)
Carnage (115-113)
DOM5153 (116-115)

For

This content is protected

LHL (114-114)

This content is protected

HOYA-UK (115-114)
djoc175 (115-114)

This content is protected

This content is protected

For

This content is protected

:

For

This content is protected

This content is protected

​

This content is protected

​

 

Good thread. I will score that one later.

Can we add other fights later?

 

I scored this a while back out of curiousity, I dont remember round by round but I gave it to Collazo by 1 point if Im honest, and Im a massive Hatton fan.

 

By all means suggest fights and I will put them into the first page and update the title. It's easier to do one at a time so we don't have **** going off all over the place, I don't like chaos. They could do with being on YouTube or such, so that we can actually score them in the cold light of day without emotion.

Once one particular fight has run its course I'll collate the scores and names in the opening page and the Brit forums results will be definitive!

 

Great idea for a thread :good

I'll look to watch and score this fight within the next few days.

 

I'll lead by example and do this sometime tonight as I have insomnia.

 

I hope you're proud of yourself TFFP? I had a night planned of Holyfield-Qawi I but I've scrapped that and I've just cued up the infinately less enjoyable Hatton-Collazo in my DVD player.

This will be the third time I've seen the fight and the first time that I've scored it properly. I'll try and be objective.....

 

Good man! Yours will be the first scorecard collated, thats gotta count for something but I'm not sure what...

Objectivity is always helpful...I'm going to pretend it isn't Hatton or Collazo, fighter A and B.

 

Your card will come in as Collazo DQ5 Hatton......

 

I had it as a draw.

 

Hatton gets on my ****ing nerves but I gave it him by one round.*

*At the time, I'll be ****ed if I'm watching again.

 

I get like that with Hopkins-calzaghe, I had Calzaghe winning but theres no way I'm going to watch it again to make sure!!

 

If you change your minds or find yourselves really bored... stop by and watch it again fellas. You at least need a final scorecard to contribute..."won by a round" isn't going to suffice

 

Such a close fight the result depends on whos judging on the night imo, it really could have gone either way

 

I had Collazo winning this one by a couple of rounds.