Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

Believe it or not I found it intersting and always enjoy watching that fight and the clash of styles,the high level chess playing.
But I haven't watched it recently.

 

What this man says^^^. Having said that I can certainly understand how people could score either the draw or a sneak win for Collazo.

 

:huh

 

114-112 to Hatton.

7-5 to Hatton, with he KD in the 1st and a 10-8 to Collazo in the 12th.

 

I Can't remember the exact scoring but I had Collazo winning by 1 round.

 

Each to their own, but the 12th was never a 10-8 for me

10-8 without a KD has to be very one sided for me

I thought Hatton had the better of much of that round

 

He was all but KO'd in that round. Fair play to him for forcing the action still but he lost that one easily.

I gave him the 11th which was really close but because he forced everything and Collazo took a breather it went in his favour.

 

Hatton had the besty of the 1st part of the round, somehow managed to stay on his feet through the middle, then finished stronger at the end. He lost the round because obviously collazo did the better work but over all I dont see how that can be called a 10-8 by anyone

 

I scored it 7-5 to Hatton - 115-112

 

Well, like I say, each to their own

It has to be VERY decisive to be a 10-8 for me


Also in the 11th Hatton landed 31 punches to 17 I believe, it was a decisive Hatton round IMO...


But that's the whole deal isn't it, these things are subjective, there is no real 'right and wrong'

 

Yeah, which is why there's some great debates to be had when it comes to boxing (providing those debating are knowledgable enough to be able to back up their points and aren't so immature as to resort to petty name-calling if someone disagrees with them).

 

I had Collazo winning by a point. I can't remember the exact score.

 

You could score it 113-113, six each with the 2 10-8 rounds

 

I am disappointed that you have not added my scorecard :-(