Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

Snap!I thought each and every round was the same.
I have to own up to watching round 9 twice-and changed my mind.

 

i watched not 100% 5, 9 and 11 twice

 

Round 1- 10-9 Barrera
Round 2- 10-9 Barrera
Round 3- 10-9 Barrera
Round 4- 10-9 Morales
Round 5- 10-9 Morales
Round 6- 10-9 Morales
Round 7- 10-9 Barrera
Round 8- 10-9 Barrera
Round 9- 10-9 Barrera
Round 10-10-9 Morales
Round 11-10-9 Morales
Round 12-10-8 Barrera

Total - 115-112 Barrera

 

To be honest as much as I love Morales, I can't see many scoring this fight for him.

 

I remember 7 being one I almost awarded to Morales for what its worth

 

Very hard fight to score but Barrera's harder more accurate punching won him every moderately tight round for me

 

What happened after the Oscar-Tito fight djoc?

 

Sorry that its wordy

Basically you had Jim Watt,Chris Eubank,Barry McGuigan and Kevin Lueshing in the studio.As we all know Oscar was on his bike(being kind) from round 9.Jim Watt said in the championship rounds,a fighter shows his true character and on that show Oscar showed he didn't want to be in the fight game any longer and that he'd earned too much money and he should go off and enjoy his life because he didn't have the hunger or desire any longer.Watt also used the Quartey fight to justify his argument,saying something was missing there

Eubanks argument was that Oscar was far from finished and to suggest he should retire after his first loss is ludicrous.McGuigan and Watt tore into Eubank saying if you cannot get up for a mega fight,he doesn't belong in the sport.....

Now I'm no fan of Oscar,but he has still acheived alot since that fight even if he did lose to the best consistently.Anyone who thinks otherwise holds him to too high a standard.(I know it can easily be argued that Oscar only beat Mayorga and lost his only defence vs Floyd,and got a gift vs Sturm and lost his first defence/unification vs Bernard).Post Trinidad,he won titles in two divisions.How many fighters become world champion atall,let alone in 2 divisions?Thats what I meant saying Eubank was right,Oscar still acheived alot after that loss,even if it didn't compare with what he'd acheived up until that fight-Watts comments were rash IMO

 

BTW,sorry to spam up the MAB/Erik section of the thread

 

Ah I missed the Hagler vs Leonard one. Will certainly do this one tomorrow.

 

round 1 10-9 barrera
round 2 10-9 barrera
round 3 10-9 morales
round 4 10-9 morales
round 5 10-9 barrera
round 6 10-9 barrera
round 710-9 morales
round 8 10-9 barrera
round 9 10-9 morales
round 10 10-9 morales
round 11 10-9 barrera
round 12 10-8 barrera
115-112 barrera wins

 

a couple of requests.de la hoya vs quartey and johnny tapia vs.paulie ayala 1

 

Thats 115-112,remember the 10-8 when adding up:good

 

nice one.never was that good at maths

 

Rd 1 Barrera
Rd 2 Barrera
Rd 3 Morales
Rd 4 Morales
Rd 5 Morales
Rd 6 Morales
Rd 7 Morales
Rd 8 Barrera
Rd 9 Morales
Rd 10 Morales
Rd 11 Barrera
Rd 12 Barrera

115-113 Morales

(please note, its how I personally scored the fight so the fake knockdown in rd 12 wasnt counted in my book but Barrera still won the rd 10-9)

Very hard fight to score & Ive seen it over 50 times, there was no loser IMO.


Mark the Butcher down for a Morales win :good