Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

100% agree

 

Barrera lost it when he allows Morales to sweep rds 3-7, Morales just plain outlanded him in all of those rds tho 3 & 4 were very close ones, the workrate & energy combined with EMs ability to continually answer all Barrera`s best attacks give him the edge.

Even if you score it for Barrera, the word robbery should be blasphemy here.

 

i gave barrera 5 and 6 and morales 3,4,7.thats the best thing bout this thread.everyone has a different opinion.

 

This is YOUR personal card, why include the mistakes of officials ?

Your score should be 115-113 MAB (unfortunately)

 

I alway score a fight with the rulings the ref has given at the time.

 

Very true & with the exception of 1 or 2 rds in this fight, most people are split, not just on who won but almost every rd, it was a see-saw, hard to score type fight.

Even tho my card has Morales the winner, I still dont feel Barrera lost if you know what I mean, neither man gave an inch despite the ferocity & greatness of this fight.
I love Morales & dislike MAB but I`ll always be grateful to him for being half of the best fight Ive ever seen.

:good

 

Why ?

The ref is an official, just like the 3 judges... why do we even score a fight period ?... why not just accept the judges verdict ?

Dont get me wrong, if a fighter keeps doing low blows etc. & the ref doesnt do **** & I feel he should have taken a point, I wont start deducting points on my own card but I think fake knock downs deserve to be called as they are... fake.

:good

 

I can see why you wouldn't count the knockdown but i was more looking to see how i would have scored it if i was the judge that night. Although i wouldn't agree it was a legit knockdown i would still score it.

 

Because usually (pretty much always TBH) I want to compare my card with the judges on the night, to see if I feel the fight was judged correctly. To do that I have to accept the same decisions they did.

 

My question to you is this,would you make such comments had it been MAB who was KD dubiously?:think

 

If it was a mirror image of the fake KD on Morales then yes... I probably wouldnt go on & on about it since it benifits MAB but I definitely would know in myself that Morales didnt deserve a 10-8 rd. I wouldnt feel comfortable going along with an officials error even tho it benefited Morales.

:good

 

OK, thats a very good point.... & if I were to follow the same rules, my new card would be......

114-113 Morales :good

 

Fellas (including me), get your cards in tonight and early tomorrow for MAB/Morales I as tomorrow night I'm nominating Oscar/Quartey!

 

:goodI got it.Good thing that KD happened really,that fight had a bit of everything

 

I'm on it straight after Wright-Ajose.