Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

Oscar de la Hoya/Felix Trinidad

Round 1- 10-10
Round 2- 9-10*
Round 3- 10-9
Round 4- 9-10*
Round 5- 10-9
Round 6- 10-9
Round 7- 10-9
Round 8- 10-9
Round 9- 9-10
Round 10-9-10
Round 11-9-10
Round 12-9-10

Total 115-114 Trinidad

Scored it 6-5-1 in rounds.The * rounds I was reluctant to award to Trinidad if I remember,Oscar was landing the cleaner punches throughout the first 8 but if you don't win the round clearly on the back foot,it is easy to award it to the guy coming forward

 

The Morales v Barrera fights go like this ....

Morales v Barrera 1 - Barrera takes by 2 rounds
Morales v Barrera 2 - Morales takes by 2 rounds
Morales v Barrera 3 - Barrera takes by 3 rounds because in round 4 or 5 Marco catches Erik with a beautiful uppercut to the very tip of the nose and it was causing Morales serious problems for the rest of the fight ....

 

My score for the Oscar-Tito fight:

Round 1: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 2: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 3: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 4: 10-9 Trinidad
Round 5: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 6: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 7: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 8: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 9: 10-9 De La Hoya
Round 10: 10-10 Even
Round 11: 10-9 Trinidad
Round 12: 10-9 Trinidad

Final score: 117-112 De La Hoya

This fight stunk to hell thanks to Don King in my opinion. One of the judges (I think it was Logist) had Tito winning 3 of the first 4 rounds then had Oscar winning the 12th. I hate saying this but Oscar was robbed to hell in my opinion, granted he didn't help his cause by running but still robbed nonetheless.

 

That is very odd indeed

 

ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (10 - 9)
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (20 - 18) Think he stole it at the end.
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (30 - 27)
ODLH 9 - 10 Trinidad (39 - 37)
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (49 - 46)
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (59 - 55) It's a procession....
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (69 - 64)
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (79 - 73) Fight over barring deductions/KD's
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (89 - 82)
ODLH 10 - 9 Trinidad (99 - 91)
ODLH 9 - 10 Trinidad (108 - 101)
ODLH 9 - 10 Trinidad (117 - 111)

117 - 111

I scored it wiiiiide.

And I thought it was clear cut.

Can't even see any swing rounds, barring maybe the 2nd?

I even gave ODLH the 9th and 10th which seems to go against the grain, but he was still landing the quantity and quality at this stage.

 

1. 10-10 Dont ususally like to share rounds but I couldnt split 'em
2. 10-9 De La Hoya
3. 9-10 Tito
4. 10-9 De La Hoya
5. 10-9 De La Hoya
6. 10-9 De La Hoya
7. 9-10 Tito
8. 10-9 De La Hoya
9. 10-9 De La Hoya
10. 9-10 Tito
11. 9-10 Tito
12. 9-10 Tito

Total 114-113 De La Hoya

I was suprised how close I called it in the end, whilst watching it it seemed Oscar was putting on a shot until round 10, even then he seemed to have it on tap, he could turn the flurries on and off when needed just chose to run instead. I was generous I think in giving Trinidad the 7th but ultimatley that was definatly Oscars fight!

 

1. DLH - close
2. DLH - stole it at the end
3. DLH - clear
4. Tito - close
5. DLH - clear
6. DLH - close
7. DLH - fairly close
8. DLH - fight over
9. DLH - again close
10. Tito - Oscar backs away
11. Tito - Oscar starts running
12. Tito - Oscar continues running

Final score.....

116-112 to Oscar. For me it was as clear a win for Oscar as the following....

Calzaghe - Kessler
Lewis - Holyfield II
Hatton - Magee

 

DLH Tito
1 10 9
2 10 9
3 10 9
4 10 10
5 10 9
6 10 9
7 10 9
8 10 9
9 10 10
10 9 10
11 9 10
12 9 10
117 113
Could easily been a shut out until the 10th. Found myself trying to give Trinidad rounds.
Absolute **** of a decision.

 

* - Close Round

1. 10-9, DLH
2. 10-9, Tito *
3. 10-9, DLH
4. 10-10
5. 10-9, DLH
6. 10-9, DLH
7. 10-9, Tito *
8. 10-9, DLH
9. 10-9, Tito *
10. 10-9, Tito
11. 10-9, Tito
12. 10-9, Tito


115-114 - Trinidad.

 

I think this is an easy one to score.

Sometimes it gets difficult to score when one guy is landing hard shots and one is landing more, but softer shots....but De La Hoya was doing both, he was landing with flurries, but also with hard right hands.

Anybody who scores it to Trinidad will have to be very generous towards him.

 

116-113 for De la hoya

 

I scored this fight before - when I had it on old VHS Video tape.

I remeber I scored it 115-113 for Oscar De La Hoya.

 

the referee in the Trinidad V De La Hoya fight.

This is what he did to himself less than a year after this fight.............................


http://www.reviewjournal.com/lvrj_home/2000/Aug-22-Tue-2000/sports/14219058.html

 

116-112 odlh

 

Can we have some kind of new rule where we have to show our cards in full, I get the feeling some people are just pulling scores out of the air.