Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

I thought it was borderline disgraceful tbh.Like you said you gave Trinidad the benefit of the doubt-you have to win clearly on the back foot.Otherwise,it is easy to credit the other mans aggression.

 

I thought it was a definite robbery.

Can't even see how people have scored it for Tito.

 

Agreed, look at my post a page or so back regarding to how one of the official judges scored certain rounds and tell me that there wasn't something extremely fishy (being kind here) going on.

 

OK, scored it again....had it closer this time....Oscar really did box beautifully in periods in this fight, made Tito look so average at points during the first half of the fight.

DLH-Trinidad

10-9
10-9
10-9
9-10
10-9
10-10*
10-9
10-9
9-10
9-10
9-10
9-10

115-114 De La Hoya

 

your not supposed to run in the championship rounds even if u are ahead 116-112 for oscar is how i scored it however your supposed to fight like a champion not run like a coward in the final rounds the judges could have been influenced by this so i dont really see the fight as highway robbery

 

But fights are scored round by round, even if Oscar laid out the Puerto Rican flag during the 12th and shat on it, it shouldn't make a difference to what has gone before.

 

I have the fight at home, it wasnt the best of fights, no drama hardly, Ive never scored it rd by rd but I remember feeling DLH had the edge.
I`ll try give it a watch soon but no promises, as said above, it wasnt the best of fights.

 

How about Eubank/Watson 1 as a future pick? I'd expect a lot of different scorecards for this.

 

I just rewatched an entire fight i'd already seen so I could score for this thread and now I'm told you're counting my score :huh

Maybe you should have stated in the thread that we had to post our entire score card.

 

oscar fought a good fight for 9 rounds he incoperated the sweet science well the use of the jab and his movement was a marvel to watch after that he fought like a coward it was disgraceful especially from some1 claiming to be the undisputed champ,. rounds 11 and 12 defy a champion u'r supposed to finish a fight like 1 a draw may have been more appropriate

 

Yea, I agree that Oscar should have fought for 12.

But it should have no bearing on the result if he decides not to. If Oscar sweeps 8 of the first 9 as I had him doing, then if he decides he wants to do an irish jig around for the remaining rounds then he still has to be the winner I'm afraid.

 

For him to win by winning the last three, he needs to have won four of the first nine, which is laughable really.

 

i just think closing the show is just as important, cant forgive any1 for running the championship rounds but i see your point:good