Brit Forum scores CONTROVERSIAL fights... #5 Brodie/Chi I

he was at dusseldorf airport with all the kronk fighters.i was drinking with jonathon banks,andy lee and sugar hill after the fight so i was talking to them and when i turned around manny was there.got a pic with him

 

come on next fight time!!!

 

I'll start it off then!Great fight, everyone knows that Marquez fought the better fight but you can't let Pacquiao get no credit for that fantastic first round. Don't mean to be boring but i had it bang on equal, 113-113!My scoring was as follows:

Pacquiao Marquez
10-6
10-9
9-10
9-10
9-10
9-10
10-9
9-10
10-10
10-9
9-10
9-10

113-113, Pacquiao only winning 4 rounds with one equal, is equal 10-10 or 9-9, I'm not too sure but doesn't really matter thats what I have it!

 

I thought JMM did enough on the night to win when I watched it but never actually scored the fight, I did and came up with 1 pt advantage to JMM, evens going into the last round.

Pac - JMM
10 - 6
10 - 9
9 - 10
9 - 10
9 - 10
9 - 10
9 - 10
9 - 10
10 - 9
10 - 9
9 - 10
9 - 10

112 - 113

 

i dont remember my exact scorecard but i had manny winning the first fight by a point.....and i had marquez winning 115-112 in the second fight, to me the second one is more controversial, thats classic marquez in the second fight....

 

I felt Marquez won both.

Both are equally controversial for differing reasons. The first wasn't even close as a contest, but for the three KDs it was a schooling. The closest I can have it is 114-111 for JMM.

The second was much closer, I have Marquez winning by one point, will post the RBRs later when my YT is working again.

 

I agree with this but I'm not too fussed with the first one being a draw, I think the second one is a bit of a shocker from the judges but c'est la vie.

 

Nice one TFFP

 

One of the biggest myths of the modern era in my opinion, if Pac won the 1st without a knockdown it would not be considered a schooling.

 

Pacquiao 10 - 6 Marquez (10 - 6)
Pacquiao 10 - 9 Marquez (20 - 15)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (29 - 25)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (38 - 35)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (47 - 45)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (56 - 55) (Marquez limited Pac to 5 clean punches, unbelievable)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (65 - 65)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (74 - 75)
Pacquiao 10 - 10 Marquez (84 - 85)
Pacquiao 10 - 9 Marquez (94 - 94)
Pacquiao 9 - 10 Marquez (103 - 104)
Pacquiao 10 - 9 Marquez (113 - 113)

113 - 113

DRAW

Wish I could separate them in the 9th, but I can't.

 

yesterday i scored chacon-boza edwards and vasquez-marquez3 cos i thought one of them would be next.off to score this one now

 

I gave it to Pacquiao by 1 point.

JMM won more rounds than Pac but the 10-6 gap at the start was just too much to catch up.

 

10-6 pac
10-9 pac
10-9 jmm
10-9 jmm
10-9jmm
10-9 jmm
10-9 pac
10-9 jmm
10-9 jmm
10-9 pac
10-9 jmm
10-9 jmm
113-112 marquez. i gave 8+9 to marquez but i wouldnt be surprised if others have them for pac

 

Pacquiao-JMM

10-6
10-9
9-10
9-10
9-10
9-10
10-9
9-10
10-9
10-9
9-10
9-10

113-112 Pacquiao....wouldn't argue with 113-112 JMM either, was really a wonderful comeback from JMM after the beating in the 1st, would have been one of the great comebacks if he got the decision.

 

Manny - JMM
1. 10 -- 6
2. 9 -- 10
3. 9 -- 10
4. 9 -- 10
5. 9 -- 10
6. 10 -- 9
7. 9 -- 10
8. 9 -- 10
9. 10 -- 9
10. 10 -- 9
11. 9 -- 10
12. 9 -- 10

112-113