Yep. I can't see how Mitchell should be above Munroe at the moment. I'd make the case for Clev as well but I can accept defeat on that one the most.
I can see why Mitchell is higher he beat the best in Britain and would be a serious contender if it wasn't for the injury. I can't see how Macklin & McCloskey aren't there but Rhodes and Small are in.
Exactly my arguement when we first started drawing this up individually:good. We'll never agree on the 15 let alone the orderatsch. I think the divisional rankings are brilliant, though.
cook should be above mitchell in the p4p rankings. also, this may be controversial, but i'm not convinced haye should be number 1. in the last year froch has beaten two genuine world top ten'ers whearas haye has been very inactive fighting just barrett in the 16 months since he beat macca. if haye's november fight does not go ahead, he should drop down a place in the rankings regardless of what happens with froch-dirrell.
I can see where Ishy and rooq are coming from so I'll add my weight to Frcoh for #1 as well for all it counts. Can we agree that Afolabi shouldn't be on there and Munroe and Cleverly should be a spot higher, though?
Yeah, the light-middle title is vacant (on my list) :good Cheers Rob, I will start inputting the lists in.
Like I said before, I am collecting all the results up and giving the best even P4P list I can. There will always be disagreements about it, that is why I want to create the list like this and just debate positions when one of the fighters in the list has fought. Remember its just a provisional list, I am waiting for more results :good
Right I have put up just the Welterweight one for now - there was mass debate yesterday when just two lists were up and I couldn't cope!