Who has the best resume of these four?

Ike Quartey: Vince Phillips, Verno Phillips

Fernando Vargas: Campas, Wright, Quartey

Vernon Forrest: Vince Phillips, Mosley x2, Quartey, Baldomir

Ricardo Mayorga: Forrest x2, Vargas


I consider these guys to be the 2nd tier of the great welter and light middleweights of the past era, behind Trinidad, De la Hoya, Mosley, and Wright.

 

Clearly Vernon, although the Quartey fight was a robery.

 

Mayorga got all the big fish. Sure, he got trampled most of the time, but strangely kept getting the big fights and superstar opponents.

 

good post. its not mayorga - he should have cracked vargas 5 or even 10 years ago for that to matter when he really was dangerous.

have to go with forrest too.

 

co-sign. would be vargas on top if the decision had gone to quartey in the forrest fight

 

forrest

 

Damnit, I meant to vote for Forrest. :wall

 

Ike did beat Vernon even Vernon knows that

 

Vernon Forrest. Add Mora to that list.

 

Mayo-de la hoya, forrest twice, vargas, tito, mosley, spinks, six heads, and piccirillo.
That's 4-5 hof'ers and 2 atgs. Id say that's not too bad.

 

mora doesnt deserve to be on that list.

 

It's Vernon, although ironically, Mayorga is 3-0 against guys on this particular list.

 

none really impresses me. guys who change turns in exposing their number by somebody else. for that reason alone i picked up Quartey. at least he doesn't fall entirely in this category

 

true but he's got a lot of losses in there

 

He didnt beat them all though..the wins and their context are the most important part IMO.