Let me play the Devil's Advocate here

I dont know what your getting at, but pound for pound isnt really only for smaller guys, its more to distinquish the best most skilled fighter of all of boxing thus the title pound for pound. I think a heavyweight can be pound for pound the best.

 

There's not too many legitimate heavyweights that could beat a prime George Foreman much less any one below his weight.

 

And...

Foreman would beat most guys that much smaller than him because they're that much smaller than him, not because he's a better fighter, just a bigger one. I don't know what your point is.

 

The term "pound for pound" originally came into use to describe things like Ray Robinson's skills, or later on, Arguello's right hand. Today it is over used, and often misused.

 

:huh

DO you mean there should be no weight classes?
Only height classes?

SO, if Hopkins was great, he would go for KLitschko? :huh

 

hahahaha this **** in mind boggling

 

wtf, that isn't logical at all.

 

Wtf?

 

Yeah why not bring Paul Williams up to fight Wlad too...he's tall

 

What?!?! You clearly don't understand the premise behind P4P.

 

I dont get it...

 

Are you joking? Are you telling me that Valuev is better in the skills department than Marquez or Mayweather? He's bigger than both and could easily knock them out. Since they cant move up to the heavyweight division, is Valuev better than them? He can beat them only because he's bigger. If they were the same size, he'd stand no chance.

 

why do you think smaller fighters moving up in weight makes them greater?