Who's the greatest fighter out of these four?

Changed my mind, I pick Mosley. I was thinking too much H2H and no enough P4P. Winky second...

Too tough to choose -_-.

 

i think trinidad is very underrated on this forum.

 

it's a tough one, when trinidad fell, he fell HARD. oscar has the best resume but lost some key fights. mosley again fought everyone and some great wins. winky i like and all, but doesn't really belong in the conversation. if pushed:

1)mosley
2)oscar
3)trinidad (it's hard but i feel he lost the fight with oscar so i can't rate him ahead)
4)winky

 

There is probably no wrong answer here, its close between all 4, good thread, but Im going with Mosely, he was the smaller guy & won the prime v prime fight vs Oscar - who IMHO beat Tito... Shane did lose to Wright twice but he was past his peak & above his best weight.
P4P, Mosely was likely the best, not by much tho.

 

felix. write me if you think else

 

:good

 

For me its Hoya over Tito..but only by a little.

Then a fairly clear gap, but no very big, between those two and Mosley. Who is in turn a bit above Winky.

Its hard because all of them have all have been involved in controversial fights that in the end have a bearing on where you rank them depending on how you actually saw those fights.

 

no bro. oscar has not beat tito, he ran for his foking life. everyone could see it in the later rounds..

 

Winky doesn't belong in the conversation??????????????????????????

Brother how can you say that????????????????????????????????

Winky Wright has been fighting world champions since 1996 for **** sake!

 

in a real world sense it has to be winky since he dominated two of the other remaining three

in a p4p sense i have to go with shane but its real close in my mind... he destroyed everyone at 135 but tito destroyed everyone at 147... and oscar well he was oscar... and like i said winky was the one with the 3-0 record against the field... so, almost as a matter of personal preference i chose shane

 

all great fighters..but with the mosley steroid incident and the tito handwrap scandal makes thing tricky >.<.......seriously though holyfield,mosley,jones,toney all tested POSITIVE for steroids..yet there still rated highly..kinda unfair for the non cheaters..why is that?

 

Damn you, I can't pick one.

 

I picked Winky. He has wins over two of the other three on the list.

 

I dont think it was the robbery everyone made out, far from it actually... but I did score it to DLH personally - but Im glad Tito got it tho, Im not a fan of Oscar, nice to see him crying like a *****.