Poll : higher on ATG list Calzaghe or Trinidad?

tito and it's not even close
only uk people or huggers would say otherwise

poll this ****

 

Calzaghe's fights 1993-2008:

-Paul Hanlon
-Paul Mason
-Spencer Alton
-Martin Rosamond
-Darren Littlewood
-Karl Barwise
-Mark Lee Dawson
-Trevor Ambrose
-Frank Minton
-Bobbie Edwards
-Robert Curry
-Tyrone Jackson
-Nick Manners
-Stephen Wilson
-Guy Standford
-Anthony Brooks
-Mark Delaney
-Warren Stowe
-Pat Lawlor
-Carlos Christie
-Tyler Hughes
-Luciano Torres
-Chris Eubank
-Branko Sobot
-Juan Gimenez
-Robin Reid
-Rick Thornberry
-David Starie
-Omar Sheika
-Richie Woodhall
-Mario Veit
-**** I got tired of typing nobody's Im skipping a few names
-Jeff Lacy
-Sakio Bika
-P Manfredo
-Kessler
-Hopkins
-Jones Jr.

Now Tito 1993-2008:

-Maurice Blocker
-Luis Gabriel Garcia
-Anthony Stephens
-Hector Camacho
-Yori Boy Campas
-Oba Carr
-Roger Turner
-Larry Barnes
-Rodney Moore
-Freddie Pendleton
-Ray Lovato
-Keving Lueshing
-Troy Waters
-Zulu
-Pernell Whitaker
-Pineda
-DLH
-David Reid
-Thiam
-Fernando Vargas
-William Joppy
-B Hop
-Cherifi
-Mayorga
-Winky Wright
-Roy Jones Jr.

 

Yes but didnt Bhop Jones and Winky beat the **** out of him ?

 

papi

 

Says the Puerto Rican :rofl

We are all a bit biased fella

 

even i am, and i'm canadian

 

That David Reid sizes up quite well against Calzaghe's Lacy

 

It doesn't matter because Calzaghe's list of opponents is hardly a good list needless to say comparing him to Tito in ATG status shouldnt be up for discussion. Tito is way higher.

 

to be honest, the hype that david reid had around him was pretty substantial, almost to lacy levels. and i honestly think that reid had more substance; he wasn't going to be a world beater or atg but he had great skills going into the trinidad and jack **** going out

 

tito's opponents pre-hopkins are nearly at oscar levels; his resume is FANTASTIC and i can't think of any names at welter that could improve it

 

TBH I think Reid had star quality.

The fight with Tito came way to soon, and Felix ruined him.

 

you could change it to vargas and that post would be just as applicable

 

I wouldn't argue with that:good

 

I don't really care about popular opinion, Ottke had some skills (just not offensive - except jab). Mitchell did not beat Ottke imo. I think greatness is achieved by overcoming challenges, and Calzaghe was too calculating. He could have been much higher than he is, but could have, would have, should have does not cut it imo in comparison to what Trinidad achieved.
Just glad that he fought some live(r) bodies late in his career.

 

Tito. Not even close