Where do you currently have Manny Pacquiao in your ATG Top list?

As a rough thought I'd say about 50, between 40 and 50. I don't really consider it until they retire.

 

Right now i voted top 40,

 

he's number 27, in between Micky Rourke and Butterbean, who beats out A-Force Audley Harrison by one spot. -jk

Manny cracks my top 30 with a convincing win over cotto

 

Top 30. Just. Maybe 30-35.

 

He might make it into my top 100 if he beats Cotto. He could be top 50 if he beat one prime fighter that was any good, but that won't happen.

 

I had him top 40 before Hatton/DLH. I now have him top 20...sometimes I think top 30 but I picture the scenario of Pac retiring right now, 10yrs on and how we will see him. With all his acomplishments, the atg's he's beaten(excuses dead and buried with time), he has a strong case for top 20. Wouldnt argue with people who say top 40 though, its highly subjective.

 

I don't have a specific list but I think top 25 is about right.

 

what if you have him as 41?

the options don't make sense

 

Barrera & Marquez were great that he beat in their prime, you can **** off with your excuses.

Hatton, Ledwaba, Sasakul were all very good opponents in their prime that he beat...you can **** off with your excuses on this one too.

 

I would probably place him just inside the top 30. I don't think it's justifiable to have him in the top 20 (which is hardly an insult - being one of the best 30 fighters who ever lived is an incredible achievement).