The better resume: PBF or JMM?

JMM didnt beat John...

 

Floyd.

 

Floyd

 

Capable guys that JMM fought from start of career to today:

Norwood
Peden
Medina
Gainer
Pac
Polo
John
Barrera
Juarez
Casamayor
Diaz
and Floyd-not yet

Capable guys that Floyd fought from start of career to today:

Hernandez
Manfredy
Augustus
Corrales
Hernandez
Chavez
Castillo
Corley
Judah
Gatti
Baldomir
Dlh
Hatton
and JMM-not yet

You make the call. Both fought other tough guys, but I put the recognizable names up...


You don't take guys off the resume becuse they lost, it's who they fought...period. Andy doesn't give a shite about anything except his Polish boxers...

 

Floyd Mayweather and I don't consider it all that close. Barrera was almost at the end of his days as an elite fighter and so was Joel Casamayor. Juan Diaz is still an open book, and Jaurez is a gate keeper at best. That said, he should really have Pacquiao on his resume in my opinion and many others.

Floyd gets it. Corrales was prime time, Castillo was still very much at his best, and Oscar was the much bigger opponent. All very good wins, in my estimation.

 

Floyd all the way. It isn't even close imo...and that is no disrespect to one of my all time personal favorites JMM. I wish they weren't even fighting...talking about Floyd and JMM lol...

 

JJM fought the better opposition but also has a few losses, close call!

 

Floyd for sure.

 

Recent opponents... win/lose
No contest. JMM. hands down.
(& in a row)

 

well theyve went opposite ways havent they?

early career floyd was fighting much harder fights

but for the past several years marquez by miles

 

Floyd pretty easily, I think JMM would have a hard time against most of Floyds list.

 

both good. floyd got the edge

 

floyd by quite a bit