The better resume: PBF or JMM?

Floyd Just. On recent activity i have JMM higher p4p.

 

Mayweather easily.

JMM has beaten like 9 Top10 contenders in his whole career. Mayweather beat 18.

JMM doesn't belong to the same category as Floyd, Jones, etc.

 

Floyd huh outside of Oscar Corrales and Castillo aren't even close to being on the level of Barrera or Manny ..Judah please Gatti please ? Chop chop

 

marquez has beat some good fighters but has pac and john who he never won in 3 fights. Floyd has DOMINATED his resume winning titles is 5 divisions and just destroying corrales, gatti, baldo, judah, hatton, hernandez, famoso, chavez 1 handed...he is a far better fighter overall...p4p, head to head or resume

 

and manny knocked him down 4 times and won both fights and barrera was past it

 

Chop chop nearly chopped Cotto in half. Chop chop was a solid mark.


Oh and Castillo and Corrales were better then the version of Barrera that Marquez fought,.

 

How does a loss tell anything about how good a fighter is?

:huh:huh:huh

Answer: NOTHING.

Taylor, RJJ and Calzaghe are all on Lacy's resume. Those three are better than Pavlik's resume combined... does that mean Lacy is better than Pavlik? And so on.. you could easily find a truely bad journeyman with rows of great fighters on his resume.. is he then really good?

No.

It is the wins - and nothing else. Losses say nothing at all in favor of the person and should of course not be used to build up the person's resume.

 

I agree. I find this thread ridiculous and it only exists because of the latino bias on ESB.

 

having the balls to fight great fighters but losing doesnt help in anyway. But a win against them will. With that, PBF takes it.

 

I was leaning towards Floyd before i realized he has fought no one of Pacquiao calibre, that coupled with his more recent wins tips it in JMM's favor.

 

JMM lost to Pac twice. You dont count losses. If you did, DLH is the greatest fighter in history.

Its called a resume. Do you put jobs you were fired at on your resume lol?

 

good point. barrera and morales are worn out prositutes by the time marquez fought them.

 

wow, pretty impressive post dan....100% agreed...:good

 

Floyd no doubt, not to say JMM resume isnt good, Floyds is just stronger.

 

I want to say JMM coz I really hate floyd......But no matter how i spin it, there's just no way JMM's resume is better than floyd....Just no way...