P4P List: 1. 224 Manny Pacquiao 2. 211 Juan Manuel Marquez 3. 191 Bernard Hopkins 4. 173 Shane Mosley 5. 158 Paul Williams 6. 149 Miguel Cotto 7. 104 Rafael Marquez 8. 92 Wladimir Klitschko 9. 81 Ivan Calderon 10. 50 Nonito Donaire 11. 47 Juan Manuel Lopez 12. 46 Chad Dawson 13. 40 Hozumi Hasegawa 14. 39 Chris John 15. 38 Vic Darchinyan ------------------------- 16. 30 Mikkel Kessler 17. 25 Kelly Pavlik 18. 19 Celestino Caballero 19. 12 Arthur Abraham 20. 11 David Haye (All points totals are out of 225). Pacquiao was voted for top spot 14 times out of 15. He was voted for most consistently alongside JMM who also was voted for 14 times in 2nd spot. Hopkins was just behind them and was voted 13 times into 3rd spot. A total of 25 people were voted for.
guys i posted the rankings on the general to get there opinion. so far so good. 1 point that came up is that Guzman is to high in the lightweight rankings, he should be around 6,7.
I agree with that. It seems he's there purely on potential, when he hasn't fought in a year and hasn't beaten anyone at Lightweight to warrant a place so high. Valero at least should be above him.
Albert Snowinski should not be in the british rankings. his fight agiasnt danny williams was not for the british title.
Even if he loses at the end of the month, IMO, Woods has proven far more at 175 than Diaconu. Anyone with me? Also, well done for putting the yellow up, Kos- looks much better:good. Maybe put the names in bold and make the division headers one font bigger as well?:think
Losfer i am behind you on the Woods call. please scroll up and get nehind some of my recent suggestions on here and british rankings.
We need some more people behind Woods above Diaconu even if he loses to Cloud at the end of the month. I'm suprised he's so low anyway! I agree. Has long has Green been on there? No way he should be on there yet so I agree on that as well:good. I like that- a pretty fair list considering that we all came up with it. I made this point as well, I believe. Guzman is there on potential- not achievement at 135. We've got to rank people on achievement- the main reason (as much as I love watching him) why Hasegawa wasn't in my P4P list.
Kos make those changes brother. Woods ahead of Diacanou, Guzman down to 5,6 at lightweight, Green out of the Cruiser and Oli back in.