Was Calzaghe an ATG?

Well Jeff, at least in future debates you have it on record at least 21 people here (so far) have actually officially admitted to knowing nothing about boxing!

 

Another poor thread.

 

nice one

 

Jeff, keep to other subjects their far more enjoyable than the JC ones

 

Holy hell in a hand basket Jeff, did he used to bully you at school or something? To deny that JC had talent at the very least is COMPLETELY ridiculous, do you at least see how completely bias you are on this subject and that your ability to rationally judge the subject is somewhere near complete zero?

God damn man.

 

RESUME.
I ****ing hate that word. Its all you ever hear on the general forum.
Oh and Jeff. Did Joe slap you about or something. You have an unhealthy hatrid for him.

 

I don't think Jeff was implying Calzaghe was not talented, just pointing out if people regard him a being a great, it's more to do with good fortune rather than just his talent.

 

I admit it is very hard to sift through your mountains of bull**** to get to your ill conceived thoughts towards a fighter I have mixed feelings about. The only reason I post in his favour is because you are ridiculously over the top, to me he is no where near the top 10 or maybe even top 50 fighters ever but if I was going to make a top 100 there is no way I could leave him off.

The fact is, he beat 2 ATG's, held multiple world championships and never lost. There are lot's of if's and but's in there BUT they are just that, history will remember Joe a lot more favourably than we do now and for good reason. He was quite simply an all time great who through himself and people not wanting to fight him, never became what he could have been, and that is one of the absolute legends of this sport. A legend; no, an ATG; it's undeniable whether you like him or not.

 

GOMEZ IS AN ALL TIME GREAT IN THIS GUYS EYES..MMMMMMM:hi:

 

The man is truly a fraud....not even close to being called a great fighter

 

michael the mouth

 

B-Hop and RJJ que the excuses I don't care about Jeff, he beat them on there soil by point decisions and he beat them after getting knocked down, shot or not he won. He beat a competitive Hopkin's with broken hands, the RJJ fight I don't see as important and mostly makes me angry that the fight didn't take place 10 years ago but I blame both men for this not just JC (really makes me sore this point, really, really wanted to see this fight in the early 00's).

PS. I amend my comment of undeniably an ATG too, "anyone who can look at this with a level head can not come to any other conclusion then him being an ATG".