Is Calzaghe GREAT or just VERY GOOD?

then why do you consider him great ? for what reason ?

 

Calzaghe is great!!!!!!

 

Have you seen what Hopkins has done to Tarver..:deal

 

Because his raw talents and skills were amazing. But that doesn't change the fact that his resume is lacking.

 

And no one knows boxing except you, right?

atsch

 

this!

 

Hamed is better IMO, not as accomplished or doesn't have better legacy but possessed more skills and athleticism, better P4P and H2H at their peaks.

 

Great, he whooped 2 of your elites on the the list. Yea they were past their primes at the time, but so was he.

 

GREAT in my eyes. I can't see who could beat him even today

 

even if joe was past his prime we will never know because we have nothing to gauge him against - and thats the story of his career.

nobody is a great if they don't challenge and beat great fighters in their prime.

calzaghe bought a lemon from frank warren and decided to line his pockets instead of chasing prime jones or hopkins.

 

thats always easy to say when you're judgng a fighter based on who he fought and when.

 

great

 

tell us why

 

Tarver's best win resulted from a lucky punch in the second round, thrown with his eyes shut.

Using that logic, you could say Rahman's best win was better than Tyson's best win and lump them together.

 

spot on.