Benn, Eubank, Calzaghe, Collins- rate in what order?

calzaghe
eubank
benn
collins (difficult to split benn n collins)


p.s how much do you wanna bet this thread turns into a calzaghe bashing fest,and a all hail prime roy jones type discussion?

oops spoke to late.

 

:huh Have we been reading a different thread? Nearly everyone has put Calzaghe top and the only arguments have been due to some people criminally underrating and some people criminally overrating Steve Collins. You seem to be looking for something that's not there.

 

dont turn it into a nationalistic debate rory..


i found it difficult to seperate benn n collins,im a fan of collins the pyatt fight was class.

 

are'nt we all.

 

spot on!!

 

:bart

 

Calzaghe
Benn

Eubank
Collins

 

Barkley
McClellan.

Now who were Eubanks and Collins best wins?

Eubank lost to Benn and Watson but got gifts.

 

wow wow wow wow....I wrote that in reply to a message that said 'note that all the Irish people are placing Collins top of the list'

 

Well according to your logic, he still has wins over Benn and Watson, unless you count stopping the opponent a 'gift' as well?

 

Spot on there I think.

 

But he still lost to both.

And lets be honest those two boxers are both usually credited as Eubanks best wins.

 

I was laughing at the post before with collins second

but

 

ok.

apologies.

 

Oirish?