Disputed decisions between 2 top fighters from past 10 years (TOP 5)

Lewis-Holyfield I

 

Good list, I would take out Barrera-Marquez and Morales-Barrera 3 though, those were clear fights IMO.

 

Both the Hopkins/Taylor fights and the second Pacman-Marquez fight.

 

Not in the same category as the other four.

 

Valuev Vs Holyfield lol

 

I thought tayylor won both of them 7-5 and marquez qon by a point but those weren't robberies but i guess they are disputed....I def though JT won the 2nd fight with BHOP and was no worse than a draw in the first one though...I will say these dec are BAD

1) Malignaggi vs Diaz
I just did not see 6 rds never mind a win that diaz won...the rds paulie won were clear...JABS count in boxing..he made diaz look really bad alot of rds and the crowd and hbo really make it seem even 8-4 paulie

2) ODH v Tito
had 200 on ODLH and i got ****ed...again tito just looked bad and anyone watching could see who the better fighter truly was that night

3) FORREST v Quartey
too show I am not biased i had 200 on forrest and he got beat that fight by quartey's bazooka jab

4) kid diamond vs miguel huerta
worse dec i ahve seen in a long time

5)Lewis Holyfield 1....worse dec i have ever seen in my life

 

Who disputes Marquez-Barrera? I realize one card was way off, but Juan CLEARLY won that fight.

 

so was JC BHOP...Bhop has got to STOP complaining if he refuses to throw punches...did he not learn his lesson from the two taylor fights that u have to throw punches to win...I though he was great defensively but just didn't do enough...he lost every rd but like 2 or 3 by a slim margin

 

I thought Oscar beat Mosley the second time around

I thought that Hopkins vs Calzaghe could've went either way ... Hopkins was landing clear accurate punches, but he was only throwing one punch at a time and Calzaghe fought his back against the wall fought harder ... and he adjusted to Hopkins style and out landed Hopkins in the championship rounds.

Barrera Marquez could've went either way but it seems as though Barrera was being eased out of the game and it was a good way to set up a rematch with Pac and phase out the game. I can tell you this, it wasn't one of Marquez' best performances.

I thought Marquez beat Pac the first time, but its hard to make a case for yourself after suffering 3 straight knockdowns. It did both fighters justice by making it a draw ... there would have been argument on both sides of there was a decisive winner.

I thought Morales won all three fights with Barrera and that **** wasn't even fair.

 

Winky vs Jermain Taylor
Corey Spinks vs Jermain Taylor
Hopkins vs Jermain Taylor (1)
Diaz vs Malignaggi
Cotto vs Clottey
Roy Jones vs Tarver (1)
Cintron vs Martinez

 

Mayweather - Castillo I
Tito - ODLH
Vasquez - Marquez III

 

Bro ... Marquez was almost knocked out in the last seconds of the 12th ... if it were for the ref calling that a knock down then Marquez would've been stopped.

 

alot of fans think Vasquez won clearly just cause he won teh 12th round so big but it was a close fight and every round from the first to the 12th counts for the same in boxing.

 

I started to see Marquez fade around the 9-10th round .... and he was getting hit more ... you can also count the 12th round 10-7