***ATG Rankings of these Fighters/Boxers***

Roughly..and only my opinion.

Roy Jones - 35-45
Manny Pacquiao - 35-45 (will likely retire higher)
Floyd Mayweather - 45-50 (will likely retire higher)
Bernard Hopkins - 50-60

Oscar De La Hoya - 70-80
Tito - 80-85 (not a hell of a lot between him and Hoya)
Erik Morales - 90-100
MAB - 90-100 (I decided to have Morales just that little bit higher, but that one goes either way)

Shane Mosley - Just outside the 100.
Joe Calzaghe - Outside the 100, below Shane but not by much..Id say both make it inside the 110 range.

Its pretty hard to judge the careers of fighters who are still active or only just retired...With a couple of years to reflect on it my rankings might be quite different.

 

Hopkins: top 50
Erik Morales: top 50
Felix Trinidad: top 50
Floyd Mayweather top 25
Calzaghe: top 75
Barrera: top 50
Pac-Man: top 30:happy
De La Hoya: top 75
Mosley top 50
Roy Jones top 20

 

:good:good:good

 

Calzaghe 100-150
Jones 15-30
Hopkins 30-50
Pacquiao 40-60
Tito 40-60
Morales 75-100
Mosley 100-200
Oscar 15-30
Mayweather 25-50
Barrera 75-125

 

Ok I also like Oscar more than MOsley but still one way or another he beat him 2 times in his prime. So i don't see how you separate them with 100 places

 

Definiteley arguable!!! But when you look at Oscar's overall body of work its what made me feel he's deserving so high a spot! In Mosley case maybe he should be up some so I can understand! 50-100 range!

 

You're out of your ****ing mind. :nut

 

De La Hoya top 15/20?

:rofl

 

Hopkins Top 35-40 ATG
EM Top 70 ATG
Tito Top 80 ATG
PBF Top 30 ATG
Calzaghe Top 75 ATG
MAB Top 90 ATG
Pac top 40 ATG
Oscar top 75 ATG
Mosley top 85 ATG
RJJ Top 20 ATG

 

Exactly.

 

I agree the guy lost every big fight he was in.:rofl

 

Bernard Hopkins - top 50
Erik Morales - top 100
Felix Trinidad - 75-100
Floyd Mayweather Jr. - top 75
Joe Calzaghe - 75-100
Marco Antonio Barrera - top 100
Manny Pacquiao - top 50
Oscar De la Hoya - top 40
Sugar Shane Mosley - top 50
Roy Jones Jr. - top 25

 

Besides Ike Quartey, I can't think of any HOF'r or future HOF'r he has beaten in their prime. Mosley beat DLH himself and knocked out a Margarito who everyone thought was indestructible.