Hands down PBF is the most skillfull boxer. But I just have to give weight to how Pac has defied the odds time and again.
I voted for Pac, though Floyd and Hopkins both have good cases. As far as Calzaghe goes, to me, he is a big question mark... Both to the nature of his fights and the time at which they occured (not to beat a dead horse, ofc).
floyd jr. is clearly he best p4p fighter of the decade. why? he's never been beaten. calzaghe was also unbeaten but didn't really start taking difficult fights until late in his career. pacquiao? he's honorable mention but again, he was beaten by a fast fading morales and got two decision gifts against marquez.
McManama, there isn't anything overrated about mayweather jr. in fact, he has the best resume of those other guys on the list!
Like I stated before, Floyd retired for almost 2 years whereas Pac kept on fighting against quality opposition. Pac has been more active and has been fighting for the majority of the decade. The question is who is best fighter and not the best boxer. Clearly Pac wins fighter of the decade. God dammit!
Like I say. Back in 99 when Pac was nobody. (Who gives an honest **** about the Flyweights? If you're not 140+ - I don't care)