I'm curious what kind of fighters just barely squeeze into the top 100's of some of the members here on Classic. If you think yourself rotating certain fighters in and out of that bracket, feel free to post them.
No particular order: Manuel Ortiz Eric Morales Marco Antonio Barrera Shane Mosley Hector Camacho Meldrick Taylor Terry Norris Jersey Joe Walcott Naseem Hamed
Having Barrera in the same bracket as Hamed is laughable. :verysad Better resume, better skills, and he actually dominated him when they fought during their respective primes. Barrera is on a different planet to Hamed, and quite frankly, so is Camacho. Meldrick Taylor and Norris didn't achieved half of what Barrera, and neither of them enjoyed more time at the top than Barrera did. Barrera should be in the top 70, as should Erik Morales, at least in my estimation.
Manuel Ortiz should be a shoe in for top 100. 15 title defences of his world title. When there was only one title!
MAB should certainly be ranked higher than Naz and so should morales. Still think Naz is fairly underated by many people however. He's got a pretty strong record.
Naz is underrated, people just hate on him, but he doesn't make a top 100 for me. People that just about make it? Off the top of my head, Calzaghe is no.100, I'd say Conteh, Morales and Marcel break in. two of them didn't have PACKED resumes but are clearly very, very talented, Morales was decent but I have Barrera about no.80 and I feel he was superior. It's hard for me, I definitely have 'brackets' that I can envision certain fighters in, but my list pretty much changes daily :good
90. Ken Buchanan 91. Jack Dempsey 92. Gilberto Roman 93. Eusebio Pedroza 94. Ossie Ocasio 95. Wilfredo Vazquez 96. Iran Barkley 97. Edwin Rosario 98. Naseem Hamed 99. Rafael Limon 100. Mike Tyson
In no order, these are the fighters I think would make my 90-100 bracket. Of course if I actually wrote the list the ten would surely be different, but these are the guys I immediately think of as occupying that sort of level: Shane Mosley Juan Manuel Marquez Jack Dempsey (the heavyweight) Wilfred Benitez Vicente Saldivar Antonio Cervantes Nicolino Locche Aaron Pryor Carlos Zarate Matthew Saad Muhammad
Mosley and Benitez could be a tad higher for me. Mosley has huge strengths in longevity, and holds wins over Oscar De La Hoya, Fernando Varga, Ricardo Mayorga, and Antonio Margarito. He's been successful above his optimal weight, a multi-weight world champion who is still going storng. Benitez was a two weight world champion when championships meant something, he was a world champion at 17 years of age, which is insane, and he holds wins over good fighters in Cervantes, Palamino, Duran, and his one punch knockout over Hope was great considering the guy was a pure boxer. His skills speak for themselves.
They are strange choices but Buchanan would make the 60-80 range, possibly. Now I'm more immersed with 'pre-Louis' fighters I'm gonna' have to re-think my entire list! Still, gives me more people to fill it up with, more headaches (of course) but hopefully a lot more knowledge and interesting tidbits to come with it.