Froch vs. Dirrell - the worst decision of 2009?

Martinez-Cintron was much worse.

That Corley fight against the 6'1" prospect was pretty bad also.

I thought Diaz-Malignaggi was worse.

Sturm-Gevor was much worse.

Dirrell-Froch was scored poorly, IMO, but there is a legitimate argument that Froch won, if you give him a few of the close early rounds based on aggressiveness.

 

yea

 

Its not even close. The Cintron-Martinez farce was far worse - not 1 but 2 blatantly incorrect/crooked decisions in the same fight...

 

Gotta say no even though I think Dirrell won the fight. Martinez vs Cintron got my vote.

 

one of the worst but not the wort ..

 

If Sturm vs Gevor was much worse it must've been like 118-110 in favor of Gevor. That's too much!
Dirrel was leading something like 115-112. 116-111, wasnt scoring it, cuz I thought Dirrel wins after 30 seconds in round 1 and he was leading big time.

 

Not even close to the worst!!! Fury Vs Mcdermott was ten times poorer.

Froch against Dirrell looked a lot closer from ringside than on the telly. At the time i scored it 115 - 112 liek 2two of the judges but when i got home a scored Froch up by one.

 

The one that sticks out in my head is Diaz-Malignaggi.

 

worst fight yes.

worst decision no.

correct decision yes.

 

Cinrton/Martinez, Malignaggi/Diaz or Berto/Collazo.

 

I didnt think Diaz-Mallignaggi was a bad decision personally, this is the worst Ive seen this year, but havent seen the Martinez fight

 

martinez-cintron is still the worst decision today by far. Cintrons gay ass dance made it even worse

 

hmmmmm i dont think it was a poor decision, the closeness of each card shows how difficult the fight was to score.

Martinez got horribly robbed against Cintron. I don't even know how he managed to con the ref into saying it was a headbutt!!!

For me, an i'll get flack for this, the worst decision was cotto v clottey. I know it was close, but I think clottey deserved it. With that one wrong scorecard he went from being a truly great WW to being a gatekeeper.

 

According to ESB Berto-Collazo was a worst decision.