And if you take into account the fact he avenged his only two loses. It makes for a pretty solid resume.
My pick is Evander Holyfield Reasons for pick: Evander Holyfield - Record 42W 10L 2D 27KO's(Won 2 WBC 6 WBA 4 IBF) titles 1 Ring Championship Belt in 2 weight divisions, Wins over Mike Tyson, Riddick Bowe, Dwight Muhammad Qawi, James Buster Douglas, George Foreman, Larry Holmes, Michael Moorer, Carlos DeLeon, Pinklon Thomas, Michael Dokes, Ray Mercer, Hasim Rahman, 7 of his 10 losses were after the age of 37 was nearly always outweighed against his opponents was past his best (was 37 and had many wars) when he Drew (Gift) and Lossed to Lennox Lewis who was a fresher and naturally much bigger man. Overall one of the greatest fighters of all time who is very underated. Thoughts,
This is boring. When I said the last 20 years, I didn't think people were going to get so uptight it would come down to saying how many months, days, hours, minutes and seconds in or out certain fights were. The two fights in question were in 1989, and this is 2009 FFS! Please remove the broom-handle from your anus and stop sweating over it. If you look at my thread-starting post, #1, you will clearly see that I stated this: Instead of wasting time and energy continuing to argue that Chavez should have been included as an option, why not do the far more constructive thing and state WHY you think he is a valid answer to the question set? I clearly did leave the option to vote for him if anyone wished to do so, I did NOT rule it out, so there's really no need to stage an impassioned fight for justice. My reason for not including JCC is because I think his peak was in the mid-80s, and his best win was outside of the time-period of this thread (Rosario in '87). But as I have said, I don't believe he is a justifiable answer to this thread anyway. I mean, do you think he has the best resume of everyone mentioned?
****!!! Where's Valuev??? Since there wasn't Valuev I had to go with Holy!!! He had EVERYTHING in the toughest divisions at it's best times!!!!!!!!
so what the **** was pac's best wins against? Spring chickens:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl Get the **** out of here
Pacquiao's resume is amazing. He retired 3 of the greatest boxers in the history of the sport and hatton.
Going purely on victories and keeping the victories in perspective, it has to be Bernard Hopkins for me. Pavlik - Younger, was expected to destroyed Bernard. Pitched a shutout. Tarver - Bigger, fresher, was expected to dominate Bernard Winky - One of the best fighters on the planet at the time Oscar De La Hoya - not prime, not shot. First time ever stopped. Glen Johnson - Only person to have ever stopped the man Trinidad - pitched a shut out, was expected to lose also. Oscar if your going purely by names. P.S - Erik Morales has an amazing resume. Marco Antonio Barrera (prime), Manny Pacquiao (prime), Jesus Chavez, Carlos Hernandez, Junior Jones, Daniel Zaragoza, In Jin Chi.
Pretty sure I said combination of wins over fighters combined with overall level of fighter fought- if you don't take each into account, it's easy to take the entire career out of proper context. As for why I say Oscar's resume is way beyond Hopkins, it's simple: Oscar fought and beat more champions and better champions. Oscar fought and beat better contenders. Oscar fought in deeper, more talented weight classes. Oscar fought the best fighters at their best weights much more often than Hopkins did. I'd love for people making the case for Hopkins to argue against the 4 statements I made above. Not to be a dick, but because I honestly would like to see it made because I think anyone who goes through the research to compare the two will wind up appreciating Hoya's resume more even if they're too stubborn to admit Oscar's is better. And finally- Even with all that considered, Oscar's only lost one more fight than Hopkins did.
I think Morales has a better resume than Lennox Lewis. You still have to consider at what point in their careers the opponents were at when they fought them. Barrera and Pacquiao were both prime when Morales beat them, and Jones, In Jin Chi, Hernandez, and Chavez were all world champions.