My Top 10 P4P list - what's yours?

Haye did not impress! He is not anywhere near my top 10 beating Valuev does not qualify, He has to ko other contenders impressively of at least beat one of the Klitchkos to deserve consideration.

 

He's done nothing recently. Holding the WBC belt for 7/8 years or whatever it was is all well and good, but it's in the past. If that was the case, guys like Holyfield & RJJ would still be P4P. It's recent achievement only, and even if we stretch recent achievement back a couple of years, all he's done is go 0-1-1 with Naito - losing his belt in the process - beat a few journeyman and claim back an interim title.

 

Wtf are you talking about knucklehead?

If anything you're the one nobody can have an objective talk about PW.

PW is a talented fighter but his resume is nothing special just cause i dont think hes the next Tommy Hearns like you and your sidekick Walk wit Me it doesnt mean im a hater.

 

:huh Why do you have Darchinyan on this list when he got ktfod to a smaller Nonito Donnaire and loss to Agbeko????? I hold out on putting Abarham in the top 10 until he gets another impressive win or wins the tournament. atsch Oh i get it you must be Armenian?

 

Or living in the past. In his mind Vic is probably fresh off a KO9 win over Mijares.

 

1. Pac
2. Floyd
3. Hopkins
4. JMM
5. Cotto
6. Mosley
7. Wlad
8. Hasegawa
9. Haye
10. Williams
11. Kessler
12. Abraham
13. Donaire
14. Vitali
15. Calderon
16. Dawson
17. Adamek
18. Caballero
19. John
20. Bradley
21. Bute

Ahh what the hell, It's been awhile since I actually plotted one of these out so I figured I'd go with the Vegas theme and make the list 21 deep...I know I'm probably not giving enough love to the lower weight classes, but honestly, I don't see enough of them to give higher rankings to guys like Calderon, etc. I gave Hasegawa a spot inside my top 10 just because the guy deserves some more props. :!:

 

Hasegawa is a little high for me, but it's good to see somebody giving him the props that he really gets. And also good to see somebody realising that Wlad is superior to Vitali. Dawson perhaps a couple of places too low aswell. Otherwise, good list. :good

 

Thanks man- it's easy to go insane nitpicking over a couple of exact spots when sometimes it's more accurate to break the list into "tiers" of fighters with about the same level of accomplishment. Maybe one day I'll cop out and do it that way. :good

 

Donaire should be number 15 He has been sliding down since beatin the overrated Darchi.

 

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Marquez
4. Mosley
5. Hopkins
6. Williams
7. Cotto
8. Donaire
9. Calderon
0. Haye

 

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Mosley
4. Cotto
5. Hopkins
6. Dawson
7. Marquez
8. W.Klitschko
9. Calderon
10. Adamek

 

Donaire?!?!?! No chance, Hasegawa instead:good

 

No :nono I've got Hasegawa just outside. It was him or Haye.

Donaire has to be in there, could be higher. :good

 

Based on what?

An overrated win over Vic?

 

He's had three tko victories since defeating Vic and moved up to defeat Rafael Concepcion for the WBA Superflyweight Interim title.

Probably got a bit carried away saying he could be higher but I definitely feel he deserves his place on the list.