would beating pacquiao make cotto p4p no.1 in your opinion?

this sounds about right

 

:rofl that avatar is hilarious... i would say top 3, but i'm a cotto fan. top 5 would be fair.

 

I think this aswell. That is if Mayweather would ever fight him.

 

no.2 for me.

Disregarding the Margo loss cos of the controversy around it, the guy is arguably undefeated with some top wins already. If PBF was still retired he would be no.1. He also holds a win over the current p4p #3 Mosley.

 

P4P is completely stupid and devoid of logic. Even in such a fantasy world I don't see how you could have Cotto at #1. Unless you have direct succesion.

 

Yeah let's disregard the fact the guy got beaten to a pulp. See what I mean? Pure fantasy land.

 

Because Cotto never won that match against clottey he got a god damn gift. Even punch stats tells the story that clottey landed more punches and was more accurate. Clottey deserves a rematch way more than mosley does:deal

 

clottey won no more than six rounds, with the knockdown he lost. that's all that matters

 

We aint disregarding ****. He got whooped end of story

The guy arguably lost once again to Clottey so what you on about

 

Disregard the fact that a guy may have cheated to win a fight. In other situations, that fight may have been ruled a No Contest. That is not fantasy, Margo was found with illegal subtance in his wraps, as far as Im aware his whole career is a no contest outside Mosley!

 

Cant change the win in the books but im sorry i had cotto clearly losing, so did many other people.

 

And your boy arguably lost to Castillo, whats your point? Cotto won. Margo cheated.

 

That's a fair point and in no way should the fight be disregarded....but there are question marks surrounding that fight now, that's without a doubt.

 

Ellerbe??

 

At least someone gave an instant rematch

What did cotto do, with mosley and clottey