Sonny Liston Vs Mike Tyson

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Rooster4Life, Nov 25, 2009.


  1. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    113,074
    48,252
    Mar 21, 2007

    ...the ones you mentioned.

    To say in a general sense that Liston did well against fighters that stood in front of him is fair if Liston generally did well against fighters that stood in front of him.
     
  2. Rise Above

    Rise Above IBHOF elector Full Member

    8,038
    39
    Sep 20, 2007
    I really think Tyson would win this matchup.
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  3. Muchmoore

    Muchmoore Guest


    I think that Patterson became smarter as he got older. Prior to Liston really, he was a very offensive HW which given his lack of size/durability is going to spell doom against upper tier punchers.
    After he was blown out by Liston, he used a smarter and more defensive gameplan, to tremendous success considering his back problems and age.

    Had the Patterson pre Liston had the gameplan/smarts of post Liston we would of seen an even more formidable HW.
     
  4. The Mongoose

    The Mongoose I honor my bets banned

    24,478
    128
    Aug 13, 2009
    Tyson can take a bigger beating than Patterson so the fight goes a few more rounds, with the end result being the same. Sorry, thats the only way I see this going down. Tyson's too fast? Patterson was just as fast on the attack if not faster than Mike and Liston was still slipping and timing him. Just a horrible match up for Tyson, who would have a better shot at Foreman than the Bear.
     
  5. AREA 53

    AREA 53 Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,466
    83
    Apr 10, 2006
    Slipping Listons Jab and coming inside. perhaps would not deliver the same results for
    This content is protected
    , that slipping The Jabs of other, "non-predatory" Fighters
    This content is protected
    Met Like Tubbs, Thomas, Biggs, Etc, acheived,
    This content is protected
    would probably Prey for an Insde Fight, Ok Give him a few Extra Inches Punching Room.

    Sometimes Mike Does not keep working when up Very Close, (As a Frazier Would) and with his feet often too close together he can be pushed back as Holyfield Showed, I actually Do not have complete faith in Either to Grit it out if things start to go against them to any great degree, Unlike against mobile Boxers who they will, all being well, belive that they can ultimately catch up with and despatch, but in this match, both would recognise the other as a Heavy Density Predator , who doesnt let woulded prey off the hook, but destroys it in Brutal quick order !

    Sometimes when
    This content is protected
    feels threatened he seems to up the Trash Talk, But would he Tell
    This content is protected
    he was going to make him his Girlfriend ? somehow i doubt it, i think they both spoke each others language,
    This content is protected
    with looks more then words, and intimidation will not work, this one would have to be won through deed, and is it not beyond the bounds of possibility that
    This content is protected
    might implode mentally and commit some horrendous Foul ? or
    This content is protected
    if he starts to take a consistent Battering might Mentally Fold as opposed to Physically, with the Physical Fold to Follow ? Both are Great "On Top" fighters its when one Slips behind that the uncertainty begins,
    This content is protected
    would probably be Favoured by the Younger Follower with Perhaps The Older Follower Favouring
    This content is protected
    ? ( I.m Probably In The Middle !)

    I would feel that
    This content is protected
    would be made the overall Bookies Favourite, But in which case would fancy an upset, i think a young - pre championship
    This content is protected
    has the determination to Make
    This content is protected
    Work and Take him to the Middle rounds, as i can see a lot of clinching and mauling, with each Fighters Bombruns being Sporadic and Short Lived, as
    This content is protected
    Tires
    This content is protected
    may find His Jab Starts to become much more Effective. once
    This content is protected
    is Comfortable with the Pace, i Can See
    This content is protected
    Winding Down Somewhat, and as
    This content is protected
    feels his Second Wind coming on, i can See maintaining the pace and Keeping the Action Steady , but steady in his Favour, Like perhaps his fight with Machen, It may depend on how a tiring
    This content is protected
    keeps it together as to wether he hears the final bell or not, if he starts Stumbling in Throwing Single shots before falling into a Clinch, i think
    This content is protected
    would at some stage catch him coming in for perhaps an 8th Round ko,

    This content is protected
    was reputed to be at his best in the Spinks Fight, BUT was spinks really that much of a barometer that night, Mercury may not freeze but Spinks surely did ! so once again
    This content is protected
    had enjoyed things so very much his own way, But what would happen if this young Man-Child Starting couldnt intimidate his young strong opponent, and started taking his own medicine from the Stoney Faced one ?

    If we are talking about A 22 - 24 year old
    This content is protected
    against a 28-29 year old
    This content is protected
    then Perhaps Sonny could of kept his (Embryonic ?) Inner demons in check long enough to get through the Dangerous early rounds until the Fight Settles down to a pace more Suited for Sonny ? He certainly has the strenght not to be bullied, Their Both Sprinters to a degree,
    This content is protected
    much the Faster, but can he stay with
    This content is protected
    over a Longer Distence ? Whilst it wouldnt Shock me if
    This content is protected
    was to Treat
    This content is protected
    Like he did Frank Bruno, i would favour the Upset with perhaps a Younger
    This content is protected
    displaying a Disipiline and fortitude not usually associated with him, perhaps unfairly because of the clay results, but this Sonny was aging and overconfident by then,

    The Younger
    This content is protected
    could certainly cope with tyson's Intimidation because he could undertand it, he was after all a past-master himself, but i do have my doubts as to wether the perhap smore all-round Talented
    This content is protected
    , - But A ManChild in his Acredited Prime, - could hold it together mentally when he finds himself on the receiving end from
    This content is protected
    !

    Truth to tell, if they both just cut loose, when the Mushroom Cloud clears it could be anyone on the canvas,
    This content is protected
    is an instinctual operator, but if
    This content is protected
    comes in behind the heavy Jab, Jams Tysons Attack Signals, puts Static in his Attic, and breeds in
    This content is protected
    a sense of caution and having to Think before firing, then Sonny could nullify any disadvantage in lack of speed and create the openings and targeting time he requires to unload successfully.

    Its easy to become seduced by
    This content is protected
    on the strengh of his usual unhindered output, but i feel
    This content is protected
    will not be nearly so effective when he has to operate while nasty Payloads are Incoming. Not from a technical "Boxer" Remember - But from a fellow destroyer

    Two Bullies, Two Great "OnTop" Fighters, Man against Man Child

    Call them what you will, I could easily of been proven wrong but

    I'd Plumb for The Younger "Prime" Stoney-Faced One.
    This content is protected
     
  6. KO KIDD

    KO KIDD Loyal Member Full Member

    30,306
    5,943
    Oct 5, 2009
    two of the scariest heavyweight champs and guys who were street tough who wanted to deal pain. I think this fight would be amazing. Though I believe Liston''s jab is the deciding factor and the fact that Tyson never beat anybody who was not afraid of him. Though Tyson's speed is very much a factor it is not a factor in the way that Ali's was a factor.
     
  7. ChrisPontius

    ChrisPontius March 8th, 1971 Full Member

    19,404
    278
    Oct 4, 2005
    I've said it before and i'll say it again: i don't think Liston's jab is going to play a key role in this fight. And it would be a fight. Neither man backs or has spent more than a few minutes in their entire careers on the backfoot. They will collide. And Tyson's clear edge in chin, huge edge in speed and marginal edge in technique and power make me favor him.


    Every Liston supporter says "Liston ate guys up who came at him". What about Tyson? How many boxers came at him? None, because they knew they'd be toast. If Sonny takes it, then he has to out-fight Tyson at every range. His slow jab is not going to do much for him, unless he's already comfortably leading the match.
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  8. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    113,074
    48,252
    Mar 21, 2007
    Liston is a superior technical boxer to Tyson. You really think otherwise Chris?

    And Holyfield went into the trenches with Tyson and kicked the **** out of him.
     
  9. lefthook89

    lefthook89 Boxing Junkie Full Member

    7,569
    82
    Sep 28, 2009
    why do people keep saying this??? its such bull****. donovan ruddock showed absolutely zero intimidation both times he fought tyson and got donimated, mcneely all though a complete can, showed no fear of tyson and got the **** kicked out of him. tony tubbs probably showed the most aggression towards tyson in his prime and got put down with one left hook.trevor berbick tried to over power tyson and the results were disasterous. there has been many people that haven't shown any fear of tyson and got their ass kicked regardless.
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  10. KO KIDD

    KO KIDD Loyal Member Full Member

    30,306
    5,943
    Oct 5, 2009
    Douglas stood his ground threw a tough jab not the paw jabs most of his opponents gave him. He was one of the few to throw combos at him. He also pushed Tyson around the ring. Holyfield showed no fear coming in and roughhousing Tyson and using his head. Tyson bit him and the man came at him with a full head of steam. Ruddock and Mcneeley were not great fighters. Liston an A+ plus no fear=Liston victory
     
  11. Muchmoore

    Muchmoore Guest

    I'd say Liston was more well rounded than Tyson. Really there's few if any fighters with more to their game than Liston, but I'd say Tyson's midrange attack/combos (basically his game) is better than anything in Liston's toolbox. But yeah, Liston as a heavyweight may be unmatched in terms of being a technical boxer, I laugh when people call him a slugger or crude.

    I'll say it again too, Tyson was more proven against various styles and sizes and thus more likely to show some weaknesses. Listons opposition (while good and very under rated) mainly consisted of guys who he had considerable size and strength advantages over.
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  12. lefthook89

    lefthook89 Boxing Junkie Full Member

    7,569
    82
    Sep 28, 2009
    this is complete nonsense KO KIDD, you specifically stated that anyone that didn't fear tyson won. there have been many opponents that didn't fear tyson and lost regardless. you managed to name a whopping two fighters in his prime that weren't afraid of him and beat him, wow! very impressed *end sarcastic remark*:patsch
     
  13. Polymath

    Polymath Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,651
    4
    Sep 29, 2007
    Its the most annoying and inaccurate cliche in boxing, after 'Roy Jones had no skills and was just fast'
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  14. ironchamp

    ironchamp Boxing Addict Full Member

    6,365
    1,033
    Sep 5, 2004
    Holyfield has the mobility, the better chin and used lateral movement mixing up his attack to neutralize Tyson. Liston for better or worse doesnt fight that way. I also think's Tyson's techinical abilities are being underrated here. He had a pretty good jab himself not to mention his technique top tier. Someone mentioned that Dempsey bob and weave was arbitrary whereas Tyson's was a pattern. There is a reason for that; he's always in a position to punch.

    Whats being looked at here is what Liston is going to do to Tyson and what's not being acknowledged is what Tyson is going to do to Liston. Tyson's notoriously fast starts, edge in hand speed and superior power is going to make Liston fight at a fast pace, one that he may not be comfortable with. Can he time Mike with his jab?

    Its possible, but all things considered Tyson certainly takes punishment
    better than Liston and when you factor in the speed and power it becomes a more compelling case for Tyson. I'd definitely make Tyson the favorite in this one.
     
    moneytheman12 likes this.
  15. ChrisPontius

    ChrisPontius March 8th, 1971 Full Member

    19,404
    278
    Oct 4, 2005
    And Ali went in with Liston and made him quit twice. What's your point? Just because Liston has a better jab doesn't necessarily make him the superior technical boxer. Tyson has better combination punching, head movement and defence in general. He never took as much punishment as Liston did against Williams in such a short time, for instance. And on the other hand, he did face many more bigger, skilled and heavy punching men. Liston isn't half as proven against that and would find out something new when facing Mikey!