Matinez/Williams: If you call robbery, let's see your RBR scores!

Williams/Martinez

Rd.1 10-10
Rd.2 9-10
Rd.3 9-10
Rd.4 10-9
Rd.5 10-9
Rd.6 10-9
Rd.7 10-9
Rd.8 10-9
Rd.9 10-9
Rd.10 9-10
Rd.11 9-10
Rd.12 9-10

Williams wins 115-114

close fight does not = robbery

If you say a fight is a robbery, you should post your scoring for every single round to justify it!

 

I agree with your scoring, a close fight does not equal a robbery. Props to both for a really good fight.

 

Not a robbery

its just tht 119 - 110 card thts messed up

Williams - Martinez
1: 9 – 10
2: 9 – 10
3: 9 – 10
4:10 – 9
5: 9 – 10
6: 10 – 9
7: 10 – 9
8: 9 - 10
9: 10 - 9
10: 9 - 10
11: 10 – 9
12: 9 – 10

113 - 115 Martinez

 

I have to watch it again. But I thought Martinez won. I think he won the first round. They both KD'd each other, Martinez's KD was a quality more damaging KD. Also I remember him landing another similar solid shot in that round.

 

Anyone who calls it a robbery didnt score the fight. They gave Martinez the fight based on the first three rounds. Fight could've went either way.

 

I had it 115-114 Martinez, so yeah, it was a close fight that could have gone either way.

 

I tried to give the benefit of the doubt in each round to williams to see if the 119-110 round could some weird way give any meaning, but I only ended with a 116-113 to Williams and my personal score 115-114 with the same rounds score like Jeff M

 

how does williams win by hitting air all night?:huh

 

Martinez: 1, 2, 3, 8, 10, 11, 12
Williams: 4, 5, 6, 7, 9

115-113 Martinez

I have no problem with Williams winning, although I thought Martinez deserved the win. There were a couple close rounds that could switch things around, but the 119-110 score leaves a bad taste. Otherwise...AWESOME fight.

 

:roll:Like I said ******s like you watched the first 3 rounds then made up your minds. Williams was hitting Martinez all fight you idiot.

 

The one score (119-110) we all know was nuts, but the fight was not a robbery. Seems most reasonable posters accept it was a very close fight and I concur.

 

Post your scorecard or buzz off!

:hi:

 

117-115 PW

I scored four rounds a draw - 1,7,8,12 because they were too close to call

10-10
10-9
10-9
9-10
9-10
9-10
10-10
10-10
9-10
10-9
9-10
10-10

 

Not a robbery just unfortunate because Martinez was slightly better and deserved a close win. A draw would be fair because it would require an immediate rematch. Now Williams is going to avoid Martinez.

 

Exactly man, that judge could have had it 115-114 for PW but the people who thought Martinez clearly won would still dispute it. There were six rounds that could have gone either way. It was a rediculous score, no doubt, but that shouldn't change the perception of the scoring. I think you could have had PW ahead by 6 or Martinez by 4 and make a good argument.