Would u consider Oscar De La Hoya an ATG?

Your out your ass! Mosley, mayweather, and hopkins are still fighting top caliber opposition to this day! They arent done!

 

Ok, that's like a 2nd string quarter back coming into play the rest of the season and going on to win the super bowl. Do you think anyone's saying he didn't do ****? Proof's in the pudding.

 

Mosley and Hopkins work for DLH

 

Let's not forget Hoya dropped himself out of Olympic running while his mother was sick and passed away, came back in right before the Olympics, this could account for it.

 

Yea, really

 

This is one of those cliches that reveals who does and who doesn't know boxing.

 

I think he barely makes it as an all time great. Although his resume is second to none, I tend to place alot of emphasis on dominating weightclasses. De La Hoya did not stay in any of the lower weghtclasses long enough to dominate them. Sure he won titles but did not clean out divisons. The first divison he tried to clean out he came out with two losses and two very close wins. With all that being said the resume makes up for not cleaning out a division. Imagine if he had cleaned out a division, if I could put him in the top 5 of one of the divisions in which he competed all time then there would be no arguement of him being an ATG, but the fact is you can't so he remains an ATG, but just barely.

 

Stupid ****ing thread he is easily an atg and a first ballot hof!!

 

Is that the same Sweet Pea that made JCC look like an amature?

 

Not even close, his speed and defense was still there but his timing and offense were lacking. Still won that fight with just a jab though.

 

yes, easily

 

Top 50 for me.

 

although oscar is dodgy and a two-faced ***** but as far as his achievement inside the ring is concerned, yes he is an ATG

 

No, it was an older, past it, Whitaker who made ole Fishnets look like a rank amateur...

 

None of the ole Fishnets nuthuggers have yet to answer the question; Exactly WHO did ole Fishnets beat to be considered an ATG?