p4p of this decade top 10s

1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Bernard Hopkins
3) Floyd Mayweather Jr.
4) Shane Mosley
5) Lennox Lewis
6) Joe Calzaghe
7) Erik Morales
8 )Juan Manuel Marquez
9) Marco Antonio Barrera
10) Roy Jones Jr.

 

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Lennox Lewis
4. Sugar Shane Mosley
5. Joe Calzaghe
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Winky Wright
8. Erik Morales
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Marco Antonio Barrera

Really cant decide which order to put 8. 9. 10. but there all definatly in there imo

 

exactly, no way does hopkins belong in the top 5.

 

Beating Tito, Oscar, Pavlik, Tarver and Wright puts him in top5 for sure. Many think he did not even lose to Taylor. Personally I had him losing the first, but winning the second.

 

got a ?? for holyfield.....MAB should take his place

 

EASY top four this:

1) Pac
2) PBF
3) BHop
4) Lewis

Then next few are fairly easy:

5) Barrera
6) Wright
7) JM Marquez

Then it's a bit trickier:

8) RJJ (the Ruiz victory puts him top 10 imo)
9) Mosley (Margarito victory just about pulls him back)
10) Calzaghe (wouldn't argue if Morales snuck in here)

 

c'mon man, we all know the stories behind these fights. trinidad, oscar, wright, and pavlik all had to come up weights to fight bernard.

the tarver win was a good one but lets face it tarver is a b-level fight who made his name out of fighting jones at the right time.

the only legit top class fighters that bernard fought at his own weight were taylor and calzaghe and he lost all 3 fights. in fact on 2nd thoughts, calzaghe had to move up weights to fight him as well.

 

Off the top of my head and with no scientific pretense:

1- Mayweather jr.
2- Hopkins
3- Pacquiao
4- Mosley
5- Jones jr.
6- Barrera
7- JM Marquez
8- Wright
9- De La Hoya (run for cover - lol)
10-Tszyu

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Erik Morales
5. Marco Antonio Barrera
6. Shane Mosley
7. Joe Calzaghe
8. Juan Manuel Marquez
9. Lennox Lewis
10. Winky Wright

1-3 is locked exactly in that order. 4-8 is locked names but order could be moved, though I think its already pretty accurate. 9-10 I think is pretty accurate.

Erik Morales & MAB over Mosley. I feel that Morales wins over MAB & Pac trumps Mosleys wins over DLH & Vargas. MAB's wins over Hamed & Morales is about even as Mosley's wins over DLH & Vargas but MAB did alot more in fighting other top contenders.

JMM could be argued over JC but to date, JMM's best win is over a past it MAB or an overrated Juan Diaz...I give it to JCC.

 

Are you guys rating on results of the last couple of years or longevity? Has pac doner more in the last year than Hopkins in the last ten?

 

I would put Floyd over Manny but that is my opinion Manny at 1st is good too. Calzaghe is fine anywhere between 3 to 6. Keep Marquez where he is. Lewis is fine there. Maybe swap Hopkins and Calzaghe. Trinidad come on he did terrible in the 2000's beat early in the decade in 01 then stayed in active to take twoi of his most embarrassing losses to Jones and Wright maybe if you said the 90's. Jones at 7 remember the 1st 5 years he was amazing and people forget that because of how he finished but you have to remember the whole deccade not just whaty happened last. Holyfield had a bad decade Donald, Iggy, Valuev, Lewis, Toney all beat him and he has had done little this decade. Vazquez a nice pick. What about Wladimir I would put him way ahead of Evander in the 00's like I said about Trinidad if it was the 90's rank him like that.

 

What does Lennox Lewis have to do with this decade and what has Holyfield done in the pass 10 years to earn a spot? Trinidad? Seriously.

 

He beat Holyfield, Tyson & Klitschko. I put him 10th.

 

PBF has been the best fighter of this decade pound for pound.

 

pac aint p4p number 1 for the last decade. How long has he been p4p number 1 now? 2 years if that. LMAO