Post your top 10 welterweights plus gatekeeper

I agree with your list but I don't get how you could possibly have Pacquiao over Mosley?

Pacquiao fought once at 147 against De La Hoya....?

 

1 mosley
2 pacquiao
3 mayweather
4 cotto
5 clottey
6 berto
7 collazo
8 margarito
9 cintron
10. quintana

GATEKEEPER-zab judah

 

1 mosley
2 pac
3 PBF
4 Margarito
5 cotto
6 Berto
7 Clottey
8 collazo
9 cintron
10. quintana

 

more like shopping for a possible dance partner for your man sd.

 

I agree with this list. Being a Pac fan, I would have him at least tied for 1st.

 

I also have mosley as no. 1 next is pac.

 

Gatekeeper: Lovemore Ndou!

 

Wow I would make a list but it would basically be this one, good list!:hat

 

Looks Good

1. Floyd I hate to admit it
2. Shane I rather see him and Pac go at it
3. Pac
4. Williams-maybe I am being too generous
5. Margarito
6. Berto- a lot of talent but still untested
7. Cotto- on his way out
8. Collazo- not championship materiel
9. Clottey- J Taylor's mini-me
10. Castillo- getting his second wind

Gatekeeper: Judah

Alvarez is still developing

 

since it's clear that mosley is considered by many to be the #1 WW (including me). i wonder how the list would look like if Berto wins... who would be #1 then? floyd, pac, or berto?

 

1. Mosely (he beat the man)
2. Pac
3. Cotto
4. Berto
5. Mayweather (I would pick him to beat a few above him, but he hasn't fought a welter in a while)
6. Clottey
7. Margarito
8. Collazo
9. Cintron
10. Alvarez

quintana as the keeper


Keith

 

1. williams
2. pacquiao
3. clottey
4. cotto
5. mosley
6. mayweather
7. margachito
8. quintana
9. judah
10. berto
gatekeeper (collazo - who may be mistakenly underrated here and might be as high as #7)

 

1 Mosley (Close fight with Cotto, beat Margarito)
2 Pac (Cotto at 145, only DLH at 147)
3 Cotto (Pac defeat aside and acknowledging he appears not to be the fighter pre-Margo, resume at 147 is better than Mayweather has proven at the weight)
4 Mayweather (Ability/potential would place him higher, 147 resume does not in my opinion)
5 Clottey (Has fought better welters than Mayweather in Cotto and Margarito, but came up short, although he has looked good in spells in those fights)
6 Berto
7 Collazo

Then it gets fuzzy.

Hard to tell how important the plaster was to previous success for Margo (will this effect volume of punches, power, how often did he put a wall in his gloves?). Will still have a solid chin. He shouldn't be allowed to fight again, but he is likely to be back with a license for the Dallas undercard.

Can Paul Williams and Cintron still make weight and be effective, how good is Senchenko, has Judah got much left, etc.

Gatekeeper: Quintana/Judah