who is pound for pound number 1

Agreed!!

The fact that Fedor is "Undefeated" and has been defeating heavyweights all his career, despite being (In all probability) a 205 framed fighter (Wearing a fat-suit) is one of the reasons that I have him the clear #1 p4p mma fighter in the world.

 

GSP mark myself, but hardly objective. Honest, at least.

 

Name the "Bum" BJ lost to :huh

 

Or GSP for that matter...curious to know which Matt is a bum...

 

:good .

 

people that have fedor 2-3 are delusional, the man is the GOAT and is the CURRENT hw champ in SF, hes gonna be P4p 1 till he retires or gets beat nuff said......gsp over fedor lol yea right.

 

Neither BJ nor GSP have lost to a "Bum".

In fact their only defeats have been to UFC champions!

The poster of that "Bum" remark must be at the wind-up!!

 

I haven't watched the fight in a long time but I recall scoring it a draw with neither fighter gaining an edge in the third deciding round. In this respect I feel you statements were unfair with regards to Serra's ability.

I must admit your logic is flawed. I could just as easily say "GSP would never lose to Jens Pulver" and cite this as a reason to rate GSP over BJ.

 

Fedor
Penn
Silva
GSP

in that order...GSP is needs to fight out of his weightclass a couple of times.

 

Fedor is p4p clearly imo.

 

Do you mean P4P #1?

Unqualified, "P4P" just by itself doesn't technically mean anything.

 

:twisted:

Damn you.

Fedor is p4p number 1, he is not a big HW at all. Like Achillis has said I bet he could make 205.

And he is clearly the greatest HW of all time.

 

Fedor has been number 1 since his pride fc days

 

Fedor is in a class all his on. He is the badest man on the planet.

 

Here's the real burning question: could Fedor beat GSP and BJ combined? :think