Trinidad was the weakest of the three. Who would win in a toe-to toe slugfest is completely irrelevant. If that counted, then Liston would be better than Ali. Baldomir would be better than Mayweather. And Sweetpea wouldn't crack the top 5 of his day. Oscar demonstrated clearly that he was h 2 h better than Tito. I had him bet of the three, till Shane exposed Marg. I rank Shane and Oscar about the same with Tito trailing by a small margin. If I really had to pick one it might be Shane. If he does well against Floyd, then he'll be the clear best.
Agreed. Oscar was a complete fighter. Could brawl, infight, box, and got toe to toe. Had speed, power and footwork. Oscar has also accomplished more than Tito and Mosley, and has beat the better opposition.
Oscar "The Golden Boy" De La Hoya 26 Title fights won 10 time world champion 6 division champion Notable wins: Whitaker Vargas Mayorga Quartey Gatti Campas Camacho Leija Ruelas Chavez Chavez Hernandez Gonzalez Paez Molina Castillejo Felix "Tito" Trinidad 20 Title fights won 4 time world champion 3 division champion Notable wins: Camacho Campas Whitaker DLH* Vargas Joppy Mayorga Reid "Sugar" Shane Mosley 18 title fights won 4 time world champion 3 division champion Notable wins: Molina Leija Diaz Margarito Vargas Vargas Mayorga DLH In that order. Also, it should also be mentioned that between the three fighters, when it came to common opponents Oscar beat them faster MOST of the time.
1.trinadad great finisher ruined many a fighter and i dont care what anyone says if oscar would have not rode his bike the last few rounds he would have been done 2. mosley beat prime oscar an any dummy that says his resume weak is wrong 3 dlh great in own right especialy early when destroyed rueals an hernandez his wins over chavez a bit overated if they were at lw or jw and 5 yr prior whould have more baring on ranking realy transinded sport lw ww finacialy all an all 3 great fighters no matter how you rank them there will always be counter argument
you didnt name carr an feld to mention vargas, campas def not same fighters when dlh faught them **** campas was stoped by not so devastating daniel santos before dlh got him as well when trinadad faught campas was like 69-0 vargas was like 18-0 an carr was 32-0 an also didnt list maruice blocker among notables an did not give mosley second win over dlh glad you didnt list sturm on oscar ledger