who is the best overall boxer of this five at JWW

Rank them in order from best to worse

Tszyu
JC Superstar
Pryor
Pacman ( only 1 fight at this weight)
Hatton

 

1.Pryor
2.Chavez
3.Pac
4.Tszyu
5.Hatton

Though to be honest, I don't see the point of having Pac in it. You can't judge a guy on one fight, irrespective of how good he looked.

 

yeah, i feel the sameway about the pac .. but i really want to include the midget on the list to see what people think

for me is like this:

JC SUPERSTAR

Pryor
Tszyu
Pac
Hatton

if you include M. Taylor . i would place him between Pryor and Tszyu

 

Seconded.

Pryor took out Arguello twice, Cervantes, and registered a pair of 15 round decision wins before he turned 30. Beating him would have required an iron chinned defensive genius like Locche. (Benitez had the defense, but not the chin.) Peppermint Frazer and Sang Hyun Kim are solid second tier stoppages of former champions. Gary Hinton was a future champion. However, Arguello may have been the greatest pair of successful title defenses in the last 30 years, certainly by stoppage.

 

1. Pac (though its hard to judge off just 1 fight)
2. JCC
3. Pryor
4. KT
5. Hatton

 

**** OFF!

I'm not surprised though, you think Manny is the best Featherweight of his generation. ...Mainly because you fancy him.

 

deal

 

I fancy his ability because it is incredible. That's about it.

 

this is off topic but why do people call Pac a Midget? He's 5 ft 6.5 I believe, just a notch away from average human height, and I think the average height in philippines is actually taller then Mexico.

 

Oh yeah I think it goes like this:

1. Chavez
2. Pryor
3. Kostya
4. Hatton

 

Morales - ATG
Barrera - ATG
Marquez - ATG
De La Hoya - ATG
Hatton - ATG
Cotto - ATG

Debuted weight at 106lbs

7 world titles in 7 different weight divisions (1st ever and only)
4 times lineal champ in 4 different weight divisions (1st ever and only)

And theres more to come at 147lbs

In 100 years time when my grandkids are posting on ESB Classic, if all his film has been lost in time, except for only this short training clip..

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qKPDeMXiJHc[/ame]

...he will be known as the no.1 P4P all time lock!

 

as for the op's question,

i'd say for acyhievement at the weight it goes;
1. Chavez
2. Pryor
3. Hatton
4. Tszyu
5. Pacquiao

but H2H at the weight it goes
1. Pacquiao
2. Pryor
3. Chavez
4. Tszyu
5. Hatton

 

I think h2h prime pryor stops all of them via insane pressure...

 

yeah possibly, although i think Pryor would have to KO Pac to win, pressure isn't a good idea against Pac and i think Pryor would have to get up off the canvas once or twice from flash knockdowns. I think 60/40 Pac wins on points(no chance he could KO Pryor).

 

:good:good:good