top20 p4p according to a panel of 28 boxing writers

Or his LOSSES!!!! Ok fine, even if you scored BOTH Taylor fights for BHop, they weren't CLEAR victories for Bernard, and the question has to be raised "Why can't the P4P #5 fighter clearly beat a fighter Cory Spinks almost, and Abraham, Froch, and Pavlik all destroyed???"

The disgusting contradiction with BHop is that he lost to Taylor and Calzaghe because of his age.......so those losses don't count to drop him from the P4P top 5 atsch

 

What an hypocrite.

 

People think he should be left off because he lost 3 years ago.

I swear, I don't see how people don't get it. A guy like Pac moves up and fights top-notch fighters and everyone thinks he's God. A fighter like Paul moves up and back down, and back up to fight tough fighters and everyone says he isn't doing anything to dominate in one particular weight class to be considered.

He is the epitome of pound for pound. He is a WW who would be favored against just about every 154, and all but one or two MW. And he's proven that he deserves to be favored against these guys.

This is a list of boxing writers. -A bunch of them, who ave very little to do with each other. So it's not just one guy with a chip on his shoulder.

This content is protected

 

david haye should be in that.

 

JMM was the #1 lightweight and P4P #1 (in my eyes) #2 in the popular view. Floyd beat him with skills, NOT SIZE OR STRENGTH.

Don't start with this **** dude.

Since '05 Floyd is 8-0
Since '05 BHop is 5-3

End of argument :deal

 

A couple of boxers ranked too high in my opinion. I thought Froch maybe had a bigger shout than Ward to be top 20, but thats just my opinion. He's made a couple of defenses of his World Title, not in the most impressive style, but a defense is a defense...
Saying that, Ward did fairly easily outbox the recognised number 1 (by many) in the division.
I always think either Klitschko should be ranked higher than they usually are, they beat all comers, including mandatories, and seem to make easy work of it.

 

????:think

 

You getthe ****in point son...:smoke

 

I'll repeat my response to the other guy

'05 - '10
Floyd is 8-0
BHop is 5-3

 

Don't compare beating Pavlik to beating JMM, at any weight. JMM is light years ahead of Pavlik in skills

And Hopkins was losing to Wright until Fat ass wright got gassed out (clearly visible) and got sloppy.

 

He's the God of PEDs.

 

Damn Reg... You ain't helping my argument here.

 

To be honest, I agree with you about that, but that example is ridiculous.